Devotees of Yorkshire Puddings may be amused to hear of a new kid on the block – the Dutch Baby. I first experienced this marvel in a pub in the Rutland area. The landlady explained that, as well as the Sunday roast, the special was a ‘Dutch Baby’. This turned out to be a dinner-plate-sized Yorkshire pudding with a filling. In fact, there were three fillings to choose from: sausage with apple sauce, chicken curry, and a vegetarian option.
Origins of the Dutch Baby
Intrigued by this interloper, I decided to research where it had come from. And guess what: there’s little about this recipe to do with the Netherlands and the Dutch. Apparently, it all goes back to a café/restaurant owned by the Manca family in Seattle, USA, who instigated an oven-baked pancake craze in the 1900s. Their original recipe was based on a German pancake, and the name ‘Dutch Baby’ allegedly came from a mispronunciation of the word Deutsch. The café, located in the German-American community of the city, originally made smaller versions as a sweet treat, usually filled with fruit and cream, which one of the owner’s daughters called babies. The name ‘Dutch Babies’ was trademarked by the Manca café in the 1940s. And here we are!
Compare and contrast…?
But I’m left wondering about the lack of reference to the Yorkshire pudding, which you might say was the ancestor of this relative newcomer. Let’s do a quick comparison and see what you think.
| Dutch Baby | Grandma’s Yorkshire Pudding |
| Ingredients 3 eggs 160ml milk 85g plain flour (sifted) 1 tsp sugar (if sweet) ¼ tsp salt 45g butter | Ingredients 2 eggs Milk to mix (½ pint/275ml) 5 tbsps plain flour (4 ½ oz/125g flour) Salt Fat or oil for cooking |
| Method Preheat the oven to 220C/Gas 7 and put a 25cm (10-inch) skillet or shallow cake tin in to heat. Mix the eggs, milk, flour, sugar (if used) and salt until smooth. Let it rest at least 25 mins. Add the butter to the hot skillet/tin and put back into oven till smoking. Pour in batter and swirl around till skillet base is completely covered. Bake for 20 mins till golden brown and puffed up. | Method Mix the ingredients gradually to the consistency of cream. Let it stand and stir occasionally, lifting a tablespoonful of the mixture to get air in. Heat the fat/oil in Yorkshire pudding tins in a very hot oven. Pour in enough mixture to cover each base. Cook in a hot oven for 10 to 15 minutes (425F, Mark 7, 220C). |
| Tips for success Use ingredients at room temperature.Rest the batter for 25 mins.Have the skillet/tin very hot before pouring in batter.Keep the oven door closed when cooking.For extra crispiness, lower the temperature to 150C and leave for a further 5 minutes in the oven. | Grandma’s tips for success Get the fat (or oil) sizzling.Get the oven very hot.Sift the flour.Use a wooden spoon to mix.Leave the batter to rest for half an hour before cooking.Don’t fill the Yorkshire pudding tins more than a third.Don’t open the oven door during cooking.Serve straightaway – have your guests waiting at the table! |
From toad-in-the-hole to ‘sweet berry baby’
I’ve discovered many variations of the Dutch Baby – from savoury to sweet – to cook up at home. Back at the pub, the sausage and apple sauce filling was a popular choice. Filled with sausages wrapped in bacon (‘pigs in blankets’) and apple sauce and served with mash, carrots, French beans, and a ball of stuffing, it was quite a fancy toad-in-the-hole (sausage cooked in a Yorkshire pudding batter) and a tasty meal!
Since then, I’ve spotted the Dutch Baby recipes with summer and autumn berries sitting on dollops of crème fraîche and ice cream, just like our own sweet Yorkshire drop which is rather like the French dessert, clafoutis de prunes.

Yorkshire Puddings have a long history, starting with the dripping puddings of the Middle Ages, including the recipe from 18th century Yorkshire cook, Hannah Glasse, and right up to the present-day traditional Sunday roast. So it’s a Yorkshire welcome to the Dutch Baby to take its place as a member of the Yorkshire pudding family. Enjoy!
And more …
You can find more about the origins of Yorkshire Puddings and Grandma Abson’s passion for baking and recipes here. And head over to @grandmaabson on Instagram to see Meryl baking with her grandchildren and find all the recipes she has compiled for Yorkshire Bylines.
More from Meryl White

What happens when the media itself becomes part of the problem? Who holds it to account? 14 years after the Leveson Inquiry reported its findings, has anything really changed? And how can we build something better?
Join Bylines Network on Wednesday 21 October, for a vital conversation about the media Britain needs — and what it will take to get there.
The event will conclude with a live audience Q&A.







