We were told after the referendum result in 2016 that negotiating the rights that we previously enjoyed as EU citizens in this country was going to be so smooth: the easiest deal in history. Except retention of our rights was not negotiated and we now find ourselves travelling to Europe with the same restrictions ‘enjoyed’ by, for example, Americans.
The UK as a third country
When my husband and I travelled to the Netherlands recently, we experienced the full impact of travelling to the EU from the UK as outsiders. This was despite the fact that my husband is an Irish passport holder.
My daughter and her partner went to Leiden University in the Netherlands in 2013 to do Masters degrees. They came back to the UK when they graduated and worked in Biotech in Leeds. But they were so appalled by what was happening in this country, that they returned to the Netherlands to work there as programmers, in 2019. In March this year our grandson was born, and we were keen to meet him!
After close scrutiny of covid rules on both the UK and Dutch government websites, and also double-checking immigration rules, we believed my husband could travel to the Netherlands as an EU citizen, and I could travel with him as his spouse.
Border control at Rotterdam
So we took the ferry from Hull to Rotterdam to see our grandson. We’d done this many times before, when the UK was a member of the EU, and the process was always smooth and quick.
Not this time.
As we exited the ferry in Rotterdam, we joined the very small queue of cars at the border, but then had to decide which of the next queues to join – EU passports (for my husband) or non-EU passports (for me). We chose the ‘Other Passports (Non-EU)’ queue, just in case.
We were pulled over immediately into a holding area, along with another British couple. It was a very unpleasant and scary feeling, and we feared the worst when our passports were then taken away.
I was reminded of this same feeling of vulnerability when driving through Europe in the 1980s/90s, when we lived in Switzerland. Being stopped and quizzed at borders, always having to have the correct documentation, it was always stressful.
I also thought about the Italian teenager and other EU citizens detained recently at the Heathrow airport detention centre. How vulnerable and scared they must have felt.
The border guard asked lots of questions about why we were travelling, though nothing about our covid status, which surprised us.
Then he asked for documentation to prove I was the spouse of an EU citizen. Initially he couldn’t say what documentation he meant, but then he asked for “a card”. Essentially he wanted proof that we were married – but we’re not in the habit of carrying our marriage certificate and none of the rules gave any indication that this would be necessary.
He then said he’d let us in this time, but next time we might not be so lucky. And he stamped my passport.
The reality of being citizens of a third country
The Dutch border guard was only ‘doing his job’. The ease of movement of travellers has now been replaced with an array of rules which will be interpreted by individual border officials as they see fit (here and in Europe). The Netherlands is a sovereign country and can determine how it interprets the EU rules of entry. Each of the 27 EU members will interpret the rules as they see fit. UK citizens are not special and will be treated as such.
As we drove away, I reflected on how unnecessary this process had been. I remembered how pre-2020, as a member of the EU, you just booked a ferry, drove off in the morning and more or less straight out of the port gate. That’s finished.
The joy of travel has now been replaced by anxiety, stress and fear for millions of people here and in Europe.
The broken promises of the Leave campaign – the right to remain in a country you may have lived in for years, enhanced fishing deals, continuing peace in Northern Ireland, maintenance of food and agricultural standards – have led to a release of a Pandora’s Box of horror.
Some of the worst traits of human beings – callousness, cynicism and xenophobia – are being played out daily at our borders. EU citizens being held and sent to detention centres and being expelled, despite having a booked interview for employment, for example.
The inhumanity and petty officialdom
The treatment of EU nationals in the UK today, under the settled status scheme, is also proving utterly inhumane – a backlog of cases of 400 thousand applications are still being processed by the Home office and a lack of a paper record confirming your status could lead to deportation.
And petty behaviour of officialdom, long endured by members of the Commonwealth, is now something all travellers can experience.
People reading this may shrug their shoulders, and think “so what?” But like the Welsh football supporters trying to get into Amsterdam, you may find yourself being pulled out of a border queue, treated with hostility, and feeling alone and afraid.
Many who voted to leave the EU (or perhaps didn’t vote at all) will find that this is all very real.
Yorkshire Bylines is a citizen-led journalism publication. We are part of a country-wide network, run almost entirely by volunteers. In Yorkshire we have 200+ writers, 10 subeditors and six people helping with our social media, but we need to support this team. Can you help us to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?
Can you help us reach more readers?