Over the last couple of days, “Christmas Eve” has been trending on social media, comparing the excitement of Christmas with the end of 18 years of Tory rule and the promise of a new era under an incoming Labour government.
Now, with the country awakening to an overwhelming Labour landslide, this sentiment reflects a palpable sense of anticipation among Labour supporters and the wider public, reminiscent of the atmosphere in 1997. The question now is whether there is that same opportunity for optimism as Sir Keir Starmer overturns three terms of Tory rule.
History in rhyming stanzas?
In May 1997, Tony Blair entered Downing Street on a wave of goodwill after a landslide election victory. His Commons majority of 179 ended 18 years of Conservative rule. Even as he walked into Downing Street for the first time as prime minister – greeted by Labour supporters waving union jacks – the scale of the victory had yet to sink in.
A few hours earlier, he had been contemplating a coalition with Paddy Ashdown’s Liberal Democrats, believing he would never gain a working majority. Blair’s popularity soared to unprecedented heights for a British prime minister in the immediate aftermath of his election victory.
Years of optimism
During Blair’s – and Gordon Brown’s – time in office, the UK economy enjoyed record growth. His government made major improvements in Britain’s public services, particularly healthcare and education, through a programme of investment and reform. Britain’s first-ever statutory minimum wage was introduced. Blair led the successful London 2012 Olympics bid and oversaw the peace process for Northern Ireland. He introduced the first elected Mayor for London, the Scottish Parliament, Welsh Assembly, and Northern Ireland Assembly.
We now know that the Private Finance Initiatives (PFIs) were storing up problems for the future and that his foreign policy, particularly with regards to Iraq, has cast a long and very black cloud over his legacy. They were, though, years of significant optimism. You don’t win three successive terms without taking the people with you. Much was achieved, a large chunk of which has been dismantled over the last 14 years, and for a good part of his tenure at Number 10, the population was supportive.
A different territory requires a different map
Political commentator John Rentoul remarked, “The sense of anticipation for Keir Starmer is palpable, but the challenges he faces are far more complex than those encountered by Tony Blair”. Many are hopeful that Starmer’s leadership can bring about a new era of reform and progress, much like Blair’s government did. However, the political landscape has changed significantly since 1997. The challenges facing Starmer are considerable, with a deeply polarised electorate, economic uncertainties, and the lasting impacts of Brexit. While there is certainly a desire for change and a better future, it remains to be seen whether Starmer can inspire the same level of optimism and achieve the same breadth of reform that characterised Blair’s early years in office.
Radical hope?
Nonetheless, the comparison to Christmas Eve suggests that there is a widespread sense of hope and anticipation. If Starmer can harness this goodwill and translate it into tangible improvements for the UK, there may indeed be a new wave of optimism on the horizon. The true test will be whether his government can deliver on its promises and address the complex issues facing the country today.
Starmer himself acknowledged the weight of expectations in a recent interview, stating, “We have a duty to repair and rebuild this country. People are looking to us for solutions, and we must not let them down.” This sentiment echoes the optimism and determination that marked Blair’s entry into office, suggesting that, despite the differences in context, there is a shared hope for a transformative period in British politics.
More from John Heywood
