You might have noticed something peculiar in the past week, a decades-old ritual starting to falter under the strain of disbelievers. This is the beginning of the end of an economic era.
Chancellor Jeremy Hunt said in an interview on Sunday that he “will be asking everyone for sacrifices”. But what are these sacrifices for? His endgame is to supposedly close a gap in public spending, where he claims the national revenue has suddenly fallen further behind our outgoings. Yet economists are arguing otherwise.
When is a fiscal black hole not a fiscal black hole?
Last week The Progressive Economy Forum (PEF) released a report entitled ‘The Dangerous Fiction of the “Fiscal Black Hole”’. The key to their argument is that it is the government’s own fiscal rules that create the black hole, it doesn’t physically exist. These fiscal rules are chosen by the government. They were last revamped when the current prime minister was Chancellor and are based on economic forecasts, not on actual income and expenditure figures.
Small changes to these forecasts can dramatically alter the size or the very existence of this black hole. If the current calculation reverted to this previous set of rules, the PEF claims this blackhole would be completely eliminated. The PEF don’t deny we are in economically difficult times, but they identify the reason why spending cuts and tax rises are unnecessary. There is no hole to fill, and it is unlikely there will be.
Unusually their work this week was picked up by the BBC’s economic correspondent Andy Verity, the start of a slow spread of the idea across the mainstream media. Other economists have been supporting their argument by targeting the government’s public justification for this black hole.
Government debt vs household debt: a false analogy
Jeremy Hunt, like his predecessors, continues to compare government debt to household debt. He claims that “families have to make sure that in the end, they can pay their bills. They don’t just max out on their credit card… It’s just the same for countries”. Whilst this is an argument effective at capturing the public’s imagination, it is not true.
Government debt is unique in that the government, unlike the average citizen unless you’re doing something quite illegal, can print money. This is not to say that you want to end up in a situation where the government is creating new money to pay its debt, but it is possible for them to do so if necessary.
Defaulting on public debt is also much less likely to happen; government revenue streams are more secure and diverse than the average household’s. We must also remember that public debt is not the sign of spending beyond our means that politicians try to make out, it is an investment in the services needed by the economy and population. There is no scenario where public debt is zero.
Poor productivity: one of the many elephants in the room
This all feeds into the wider anti-austerity argument, the world-renowned economist Ha-Joon Chang tapped into this further on Newsnight last Friday, affirming that “cutting government spending during an economic downturn doesn’t actually work”. He cited the fact that at the start of George Osborne’s programme of austerity in 2010 government debt was 60% of GDP, whereas by the eve of the pandemic in 2020 it had risen to 80%. When you cut spending, you also cut the potential to earn.
Chang also called out Britain’s failure to invest in “productive capabilities” over the last 25 years, something which the latest statistics continue to support. Campaign group Pregnant Then Screwed reports that there are now “at least 870,000 stay-at-home mums who want to work but can’t afford childcare”. The UK has failed to invest in improving childcare over the last decade, instead targeting it for relative terms cuts. The result of this is a smaller and less productive workforce.
A further 400,000 people have left the workforce since 2020 due to long-term illness, bringing the total number of people not seeking work due to a long-term illness to a record high of 2.5m. This total includes an increasing proportion of younger workers. Failure to invest in healthcare and measures which protect health has added even greater pressure to Britain’s productivity problem.
One of the least generous statutory sick pay schemes in Europe also ensures workers are discouraged from prioritising their long-term health and are forced onto benefits when they cannot work for any length of time. These failures to invest are of course aside from wider public sector cuts which all contribute to lower productivity, whether it be through lack of access to education or needing to leave work to care for dependents where the social care sector cannot.
Time to abandon rigid orthodoxy and tired ideology
All the evidence points to austerity leaving the economy worse off. Rather than being necessary to manage or avoid a recession, it deepens them. So if this is the case, why do politicians keep suggesting Britain swallows its ineffective medicine for an illness it does not have? For the Labour Party, this seems to be for the economic credibility that comes as part of the package. Much of the premise of these ideas is built on what is known as Treasury Orthodoxy, in short this is stuff that has been around a long time and that governments of both colours have by and large gone along with.
At the moment, Labour’s shadow chancellor Rachel Reeves is attacking further austerity, but has not gone so far as to dismiss the black hole. She instead suggests alternative sources of revenue to cover the supposed shortfall, including further windfall taxes. To break from these norms before the alternative is digested by the general public may avoid a financial deficit, but for Labour it may create an electoral one.
Meanwhile in the Conservative camp the reasoning is a little less logical, their adhesion to these policies represents a last act of devotion to a dying era. These fiscal rules and economic ideas represent everything their party has been built on since the 1980s. Without excuses for spending cuts they cannot create a small state, they cannot worship finance and big business in the same puritan way. This is what they ask you to sacrifice for – their own ideology – because without sacrifice the face of God falls from the economic status quo and its failure is exposed.
Our economy is not the creator of our fortune, it is a restraint on it. It is not the conscience of the mythical markets, it is the driving force of inequality. It is not an unquestionable ruler in the sky, it is something we believed for a while. There are new ideas out there, it’s time to move on.







