• Contact
  • About
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
Yorkshire Bylines
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Home Affairs
    • Transport
    • World
    Sunak to leave 18,000 EU laws

    Will Sunak leave nearly 18,000 EU laws on the statute book?

    Common swift

    Forty-seven and still counting: making swift changes in Masham!

    rewilding Bransholme

    Rewilding Bransholme: success at Europe’s ‘biggest council estate’

    Cartoon man in suit and bowler hat in front of a graph with inflation figures going sky high

    Growth, recession and inflation loom, but there’s an alternative

    reproductive rights

    UK undermines international support for reproductive rights

    Picture of car tyre being deflated along with a notice to the owner saying it's not about them, it's about their car

    Environmentalists target SUVs in Leeds and deflate their tyres in climate protest

    the proclaimers

    The Proclaimers set walking challenge for Yorkshire and the Humber

    road traffic collisions

    Road traffic collisions and automatism: families deserve justice

    House on a new estate in Bedford

    Leading social charity calls for renting reforms

    Trending Tags

    • Johnson
    • Coronavirus
    • Labour
    • Starmer
    • Northern Ireland protocol
    • Brexit
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Home Affairs
    • Transport
    • World
  • Politics
  • Opinion
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Culture
    • Dance
    • Food
    • Music
    • Poetry
    • Recipes
    • Sport
    slaithwaite history

    Norky’s ramblings: radicals and subversives

    Ruth and Pete

    A very personal blog: the gift

    christina aguilera scarborough

    Christina Aguilera: feeling the moment at Scarborough open air theatre

    musician mental health

    Let’s talk about musicians’ mental health

    Harrogate cenotaph, a war memorial to soldiers who died in the 1st and 2nd world wars

    God’s own spa resort in Harrogate

    Cawthorne Museum

    Yorkshire’s little museums and galleries: good things come in small packages

    Sleeping puppy rests in arm of woman wearing a sweater.

    For the love of dog: celebrating humanity’s oldest friendship

    Pebbles, with the word "hope" on them, image by Nick Fewings for unsplash

    A very personal blog: hope

    Scene from Waitress

    Waitress – serving up a real treat at the Alhambra, Bradford

    • Food
    • Music
    • Poetry
    • Sport
  • Business
    • All
    • Economy
    • Technology
    • Trade
    Model of a large man standing on a pound coin

    We can solve the cost-of-living crisis

    Gas hob

    Energy costs and the Don’t Pay campaign

    doomsday clock

    Anxiety about nuclear war escalates as the Doomsday Clock ticks closer to midnight

    Cartoon man in suit and bowler hat in front of a graph with inflation figures going sky high

    Growth, recession and inflation loom, but there’s an alternative

    photo of a piggy bank with pork going in it

    Legal action into pork-barrel politics and the Towns Fund

    House on a new estate in Bedford

    Leading social charity calls for renting reforms

    tiny figures on piles of coins

    “We’re stabbing in the dark”, experts and MPs slam Levelling Up Bill

    bbc broadcasting operator

    Switched-On – A journey through a century of broadcasting

    phone box

    Norky’s ramblings: when I was a lad, that would never happen

    Trending Tags

      • Economy
      • Technology
      • Trade
    • Region
    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • News
      • All
      • Brexit
      • Education
      • Environment
      • Health
      • Home Affairs
      • Transport
      • World
      Sunak to leave 18,000 EU laws

      Will Sunak leave nearly 18,000 EU laws on the statute book?

      Common swift

      Forty-seven and still counting: making swift changes in Masham!

      rewilding Bransholme

      Rewilding Bransholme: success at Europe’s ‘biggest council estate’

      Cartoon man in suit and bowler hat in front of a graph with inflation figures going sky high

      Growth, recession and inflation loom, but there’s an alternative

      reproductive rights

      UK undermines international support for reproductive rights

      Picture of car tyre being deflated along with a notice to the owner saying it's not about them, it's about their car

      Environmentalists target SUVs in Leeds and deflate their tyres in climate protest

      the proclaimers

      The Proclaimers set walking challenge for Yorkshire and the Humber

      road traffic collisions

      Road traffic collisions and automatism: families deserve justice

      House on a new estate in Bedford

      Leading social charity calls for renting reforms

      Trending Tags

      • Johnson
      • Coronavirus
      • Labour
      • Starmer
      • Northern Ireland protocol
      • Brexit
      • Culture
      • Education
      • Environment
      • Home Affairs
      • Transport
      • World
    • Politics
    • Opinion
    • Lifestyle
      • All
      • Culture
      • Dance
      • Food
      • Music
      • Poetry
      • Recipes
      • Sport
      slaithwaite history

      Norky’s ramblings: radicals and subversives

      Ruth and Pete

      A very personal blog: the gift

      christina aguilera scarborough

      Christina Aguilera: feeling the moment at Scarborough open air theatre

      musician mental health

      Let’s talk about musicians’ mental health

      Harrogate cenotaph, a war memorial to soldiers who died in the 1st and 2nd world wars

      God’s own spa resort in Harrogate

      Cawthorne Museum

      Yorkshire’s little museums and galleries: good things come in small packages

      Sleeping puppy rests in arm of woman wearing a sweater.

      For the love of dog: celebrating humanity’s oldest friendship

      Pebbles, with the word "hope" on them, image by Nick Fewings for unsplash

      A very personal blog: hope

      Scene from Waitress

      Waitress – serving up a real treat at the Alhambra, Bradford

      • Food
      • Music
      • Poetry
      • Sport
    • Business
      • All
      • Economy
      • Technology
      • Trade
      Model of a large man standing on a pound coin

      We can solve the cost-of-living crisis

      Gas hob

      Energy costs and the Don’t Pay campaign

      doomsday clock

      Anxiety about nuclear war escalates as the Doomsday Clock ticks closer to midnight

      Cartoon man in suit and bowler hat in front of a graph with inflation figures going sky high

      Growth, recession and inflation loom, but there’s an alternative

      photo of a piggy bank with pork going in it

      Legal action into pork-barrel politics and the Towns Fund

      House on a new estate in Bedford

      Leading social charity calls for renting reforms

      tiny figures on piles of coins

      “We’re stabbing in the dark”, experts and MPs slam Levelling Up Bill

      bbc broadcasting operator

      Switched-On – A journey through a century of broadcasting

      phone box

      Norky’s ramblings: when I was a lad, that would never happen

      Trending Tags

        • Economy
        • Technology
        • Trade
      • Region
      No Result
      View All Result
      Yorkshire Bylines
      No Result
      View All Result
      Home Politics

      Let’s learn from Brexit and give Scottish independence the debate it deserves

      We all saw first-hand the consequences of a poorly-informed debate on Brexit. The Scottish independence debate holds all the same risks, and we have the opportunity to make it a more substantive discussion.

      Alex ToalbyAlex Toal
      30-01-2021 13:00
      in Politics
      "Darnford Farm in Aberdeenshire" image by UK Prime Minister for Creative Commons

      "Darnford Farm in Aberdeenshire" image by UK Prime Minister for Creative Commons

      12
      VIEWS
      Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
      ADVERTISEMENT

      Boris Johnson’s ‘charm offensive’ in Scotland ended up being more offensive than charm, and showed just how dire the debate on independence may turn out to be. As Scottish politicians attacked Johnson for daring to venture north, the prime minister, having previously claimed that Scottish devolution had been a “disaster”, now decided that the moment called on him to argue that independence was “irrelevant” to most Scots.

      Journalists have rightly pointed out how both sides’ positions are essentially reversed from where they were on Brexit. This mirror image was best described by Philip Collins in the New Statesman:

      “One side of the argument runs that a country should be an independent, sovereign unit. Boris Johnson on Brexit turns into Nicola Sturgeon on Scottish independence. This is then countered by the case that we are richer together and it is foolish to impoverish ourselves for a fantasy account of national sovereignty in a networked world. Johnson on Scottish independence is indistinguishable from Sturgeon on Brexit.”

      In many ways, the argument is just Brexit on steroids. Just as the control that Westminster has over Scotland is greater than that which Brussels had over Britain, so too are Scotland and England bound tighter than the UK and Europe were. The separation negotiations would take even longer, and be even more acrimonious, not to mention the difficulties of erecting another land border.

      It is for that very reason that we owe it to the people of Scotland to raise the level of the debate above the rhetoric of both supporters and opponents of independence. If you truly want Scotland to stay in the Union, you need to recognise that, since the new millennium, wars, austerity, and Brexit were all forced upon the country against its will, and that it needs to have a greater say in its own affairs.

      On the other hand, if you genuinely think that Scotland is better off on its own, you’re going to do the country no good in the long-term by glossing over the potential trade-offs.

      We’ve all seen first-hand the consequences of the poor quality of the Brexit debate. A close result, accusations of dishonesty, and uncertainty of what Brexit should look like, led to the result lacking legitimacy in the eyes many Remainers, whose outcome took years of toxic debate to settle. Whatever the results of another independence referendum, it’s unlikely that it would be immune from these same issues.

      If we are to learn from these mistakes, then we should ensure that the following. Firstly, Johnson should not stand in the way of another referendum, particularly if a pro-independence government is returned to Holyrood in May. Moreover, in the event that the people of Scotland choose to leave, whatever deal is reached should be subject to a confirmatory referendum.

      Finally, we should approach this debate with solemnity rather than rage, and recognise the sorry state of affairs that has led to one nation of the United Kingdom considering the risks of independence just to separate itself from Westminster’s poor governance.

      No one really knows whether Scottish independence is a good thing or not, but both sides shouting at each other for months on end will not help us get any closer to an answer. Only if each camp recognises the complexity of the debate, and pledges to make union or separation a success, whatever the result, will we do right by those who will be impacted by the decision.

      Tags: DevolutionJohnson
      ADVERTISEMENT
      Previous Post

      Norky’s ramblings: uncles in the war (part 1)

      Next Post

      What would proportional representation look like?

      Alex Toal

      Alex Toal

      Alex is the Bylines Network's audience development officer. A graduate of the University of York and Balliol College, Oxford, he is a passionate devolutionist, and an active campaigner in the effort for equal votes.

      Related Posts

      The Multiverse
      Opinion

      Governance and the multiverse: can one compromised politician change the fate of empires?

      byDr Pam Jarvis
      8 August 2022
      reproductive rights
      Home Affairs

      UK undermines international support for reproductive rights

      byHelen Johnson
      7 August 2022
      Policy in Motion with Liz Truss, cartoon by Stan
      Opinion

      Johnson taught Truss everything she doesn’t know

      bySue Wilson MBE
      5 August 2022
      northern powerhouse rail
      Politics

      Truss tries to win over Northern Tories with Northern Powerhouse promises

      byAndy Brown
      3 August 2022
      Truss doing Highland dancing in a blank kilt with her advisors ready to crayon in the desired colours
      Opinion

      Shapeshifter Liz TrUss is more dizzy than fizzy

      byJuvenal
      2 August 2022
      Next Post
      Polling station image by  thedescrier for Creative Commons

      What would proportional representation look like?

      Want to support us?

      Can you help Yorkshire Bylines to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?  

      DONATE

      Sign up to our newsletter

      If you would like to receive the Yorkshire Bylines regular newsletter, straight talking direct to your inbox, click the button below.

      NEWSLETTER

      LATEST

      Model of a large man standing on a pound coin

      We can solve the cost-of-living crisis

      10 August 2022
      Gas hob

      Energy costs and the Don’t Pay campaign

      9 August 2022
      Sunak to leave 18,000 EU laws

      Will Sunak leave nearly 18,000 EU laws on the statute book?

      9 August 2022
      Common swift

      Forty-seven and still counting: making swift changes in Masham!

      9 August 2022

      MOST READ

      Photo credit Robert Sharp / englishpenLicensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license.

      The Davis Downside Dossier

      5 August 2022
      Sunak to leave 18,000 EU laws

      Will Sunak leave nearly 18,000 EU laws on the statute book?

      9 August 2022
      Jacob Rees-Mogg, cartoon by Stan

      Brexit benefits: From Honduras to Hull, via Hong Kong

      9 June 2022
      Cartoon man in suit and bowler hat in front of a graph with inflation figures going sky high

      Growth, recession and inflation loom, but there’s an alternative

      8 August 2022

      BROWSE BY TAGS

      antivaxxers Charity Climate change Coronavirus Cost of living Creative industries Crime Cummings Davis Downside Dossier Democracy Devolution Equality Farming Fishing History Immigration Johnson Journalism Labour Levelling up Liz Truss Mental health NHS Northern Ireland protocol Pollution Poverty PPE Starmer Travel Ukraine
      Yorkshire Bylines

      We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Yorkshire and beyond.

      Yorkshire Bylines is a trading brand of Bylines Network Limited, which is a sister organisation to Byline Times.

      Learn more about us

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Contact
      • About
      • Letters
      • Donate
      • Privacy
      • Bylines network

      © 2022 Yorkshire Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist.

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • News
        • Brexit
        • Education
        • Environment
        • Health
        • Home Affairs
        • Transport
        • World
      • Politics
      • Opinion
      • Lifestyle
        • Culture
        • Dance
        • Food
        • Music
        • Poetry
        • Recipes
        • Sport
      • Business
        • Economy
        • Technology
        • Trade
      • Donate
      • The Compendium of Cabinet Codebreakers
      • The Davis Downside Dossier
      • The Digby Jones Index
      • Newsletter sign up
      • Cartoons by Stan
      • Authors

      © 2022 Yorkshire Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist.

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password?

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In