On Wednesday I was out putting letters through letterboxes, inviting people to come and talk about politics, full of optimism, with spring flowers reminding me of renewed hope. I went for a British sign language lesson (I’m getting my hearing aids in March … hooray) and when I came back to my phone less than an hour later it was hot with messages about friends leaving the Labour party! I was reeling at the message that the Labour’s green U-turn, apparently reneging on its policies – and I got caught up in it.
Let’s face it, Britain is broken, and many of us are hanging on for change so that we can start the recovery. But there isn’t an easy answer.
It’s depressing, and I don’t use that word at all lightly. People are having to make difficult choices, and for some, there is no choice because the mortgage bill that is coming cannot be met by income no matter how hard they work, so the debt mounts. Many are despondent and want nothing to do with politics, others are ready to shout loudly about injustice at every opportunity. This time, though, the message from Labour was wrong.
Labour’s green U-turn: it’s not what you think it is
Our television screens are full of poverty, war and senseless murders. On top of that, we hear that big plans to save the planet for the future have been downgraded. It feels like a ‘What next?!’ and we want to lash out and protest. Some are just sad and can’t manage to shout, others feel that in their busy and difficult lives they must still make some noise and so they leave the Labour Party. It feels like doing something, I get it. I believe it is doing something, but not with the effect you think it will have.
What it does is add credence to the Conservative rhetoric that the Labour Party is changing its mind again, which aids them in staying in power. When friends say to me that they are leaving the party, I ask them what alternative they prefer? Don’t they want a stable party of integrity to get in and show what they can do? I realise that leaving the party does not mean that they will not vote for it, but we need positive reinforcement that the people want change, and to be seen to be campaigning for a better society.
Hard truths and dreams
Keir Starmer and the Labour Party are not in power. I hear, every day, about what the party is not doing or about plans changing, but that is the frustration of being in opposition. Where we want to make a difference, we can’t yet, and whilst the parameters are constantly changing it is difficult to set out a concrete plan.
The party set out what it wants to do at conference: get Britain building again; switch on Great British Energy; get the NHS back on its feet; take back our streets; and break down barriers to opportunity. But what do you do when you have a plan for your shopping list, your holidays, your life and then things change? Do you plough on thinking it’ll be okay, we’ll still be able to afford the salmon this weekend, the holiday abroad, my early retirement, or do you have to think again? Some things in life are beyond our control and, frustrating as it might be, we have to react.
In his new year speech Starmer spoke of “a politics that treads a little lighter on all our lives”. It reminded me of Yeats’ poem He Wishes for the Cloths of Heaven (“Tread softly because you tread on my dreams”).
To think that we could have a government that actually does what they are meant to do, with integrity, so that the rest of us can get on with life, is heartwarming, and in Starmer we have someone who we could trust to get on with the job. The change to the green prosperity plan does not mean that we will not meet the goal of clean power by 2030, or that funding for Great British Energy has been thrown out; it means that the party is having to adjust, still, to what the government is doing, and make plans to be fiscally responsible.
As Starmer reminds us:
“None of us could have predicted the damage the Conservatives would do when they crashed the economy … it is the inheritance we will face if we are elected.”
It is still Labour’s plan to create jobs, to make bills cheaper, to tackle the climate emergency, and to give Britain its future back.
Messaging
What happened when so many people became upset at what they saw as Labour’s going back on the green prosperity plan was the fault of the message we received. The reality-TV culture we have come to expect set this up to be a big announcement of ditching environmental policies. It is not. Perhaps we are triggered into latching onto something we can shout about when every other action seems futile; something we have control over and which we believe will make a difference.
Well, I would say that this coming year will be a test of whether we can make a true difference for the people of this country – and a real difference is what we all need. Just make sure you are aiming your energy in the right direction.
Don’t be misled by repeated empty word slogans set to distract and sway you from the truth. Rather than letting your action be a negative one of despair, make it count towards change. Make no mistake, the Conservatives have broken Britain and the only way to start rebuilding, hard as that task will be, will be to back a Labour government so that it can see its policies through to a manifesto which works and rebuilds our society.







