On January 11 this year, Yorkshire Bylines published my analysis of the runners and riders in a potential Conservative Party leadership election. As the contest limps towards its conclusion and the winner is due to be declared on 5 September, it occurred to me that now would be a good time to look back at what I got right and what I got wrong.
It’s been a dismal election. While the Conservatives have been electing a new leader, the country has been plummeting toward a catastrophic energy crisis. Low and middle-income Britain is gripped by inflation, the Brexit aftermath and soaring energy prices. But what are the main priorities of Tory members? There is only one – tax cuts. Inflation is predicted to rise to 18%? Tax cuts. The average family is predicted to pay more than £3,000 in energy bills by the end of the year? Tax cuts. Millions of pensions, parents of disabled children and low-income families being pushed into poverty? Tax cuts.
The bind the Conservative Party finds itself in is that, unlike the global financial crisis of 2008, the current economic crisis does not follow ten years of rising living standards. This crisis follows over ten years of austerity, flatlining wages and low productivity. Low and middle-income Britain cannot simply afford to pay rocketing prices and energy bills. Liz Truss’s eye-catching tax proposals, conjured to woo the Tory faithful (a YouGov poll last week gave her a 32-point lead over her rival), will almost certainly turn a bad winter recession into a terrible one. But the prospect of a catastrophic winter recession doesn’t seem to perturb Conservative Party members. Their little tax band is the god before whom they must bow.
Looking back at my piece entitled ‘Conservative Party: In a leadership election, who will be the runners and riders?’, some of my predictions proved remarkably accurate and some less so. Here’s what I got right.
The final two: Sunak vs Truss
In my article, I gave odds to every potential candidate listed. I gave the best odds to Rishi Sunak (2/1) and Liz Truss (4/1). These were far and away the best odds of every potential candidate, the next candidate on my list was Michael Gove (5/1), who chose not to stand at all. Despite a concerted effort from Penny Mordaunt, whose campaign got off to a good start with a campaign video that had clearly been prepared months in advance and at great expense, it was Truss who finally made it onto the final ballot along with Rishi Sunak.
Rishi Sunak’s ‘comeback’
When I proposed that Sunak would be a shoo-in for the final two, there were some who suggested that I was over-selling him. At the time, in the wake of the numerous scandals that had irretrievably damaged Boris Johnson, such as ‘partygate’ and wilful disregard for his own Covid-19 rules, some people suggested that Sunak had been damaged by these revelations. Particularly when it was revealed that he had been in attendance at some of the Downing Street parties. Sunak’s reputation was damaged further by implementing an unpopular rise in national insurance contributions prior to the leadership election.
Ultimately, Sunak made the final ballot comfortably, receiving the votes of 137 Tory MPs.
And here’s what I got wrong …
The other runners and riders
Michael Gove, Jeremy Hunt, Priti Patel and Dominic Raab were the other Tories I predicted may be in with a chance. In the event, three of them didn’t stand at all. The only one who did, Jeremy Hunt, folded his tent early on.
And who could possibly ignore …
Cuts, cuts, cuts
The party’s obsession with tax cuts is simply breath-taking. For a party that has been much trumpeted as the new ‘worker’s party’ (supposedly) and the natural party of government with its finger on the pulse of middle and low-income Britain, it seems Tory members didn’t get the memo.
Sunak’s campaign is right when it says that Truss’s proposed tax cuts won’t “touch the sides” when it comes to making a difference to people’s lives in the current crisis. The Resolution Foundation in its report on the coming winter crisis said that the tax cuts Truss proposes will save the average low-to-middle income earner between £85 to £124 a month, which is little comfort when the energy price cap will go up to over £3,000 for the average household.
It has been eye-opening to realise how ideologically committed Conservative members are to tax cuts. If a pensioner dies in their own home or a family with small children is pushed into poverty, then that, they have concluded, is a reasonable price to pay for reducing tax. I have concluded that the average party member simply isn’t that political. They don’t care about the country, how the economy will look in four to five years time, or the societal welfare of the nation. The only thing they care about are tax cuts, tax cuts, tax cuts, a bit of flag-waving, a few barbs against ‘woke culture’. And that’s it. Amazing.
What happens now?
Hunt and his little group in parliament threw his weight behind Sunak. The group surrounding Hunt is a good ‘temperature check’ of a Tory leadership election. Typically, the candidate who this loose grouping backs, wins the election. As it stands now, barring some kind of last-minute shock, Truss is fated to be the out-and-out winner. This places the Tory party on the brink of a potentially huge split. For the first time in a long time, the Tory leader is the overwhelming choice of the members, and the second choice of Tory MPs.
The overwhelming priority for the new prime minister must be to get energy costs down. It seems plausible that a new Truss-led administration will be bounced into dishing out the handouts she so witheringly dismissed in her election campaign. Truss may find herself reneging on her promise to cut taxes faced with the economic reality of a winter fuel crisis. Similarly, it will be hard for her to ‘unleash the potential of Brexit’ when people are flinging bins through supermarket windows because they can’t afford food. In promising the party faithful the moon on a stick, Truss has set the fantasies of Conservative Party members on an inescapable collision course with reality. That has consequences.







