Cast your mind back to the shambles of the Boris Johnson government, and remind yourself of the mess that was Number 10 Downing Street, and it will be obvious that the system needs change. Even today, executive power is so concentrated in the hands of the prime minister and his small inner circle that it hardly represents a democratic structure.
The Commission on Political Power, a group of experts in constitutional reform, has published three short papers setting out ideas for how our democratic structures could be improved – and at the heart of the problem is the executive.
Executive power has become so uncontrolled that it fosters venality, mendacity and corruption. In order to constrain what is becoming an increasingly presidential-style government, but without the checks and balances normal in, say, the French or American systems, we need to change things. The commission has set out some options for reform, many of them are technocratic, but such incremental change is inherent in the nature of the British system.
Legislate on representatives’ roles and boundaries
We think the roles of the prime minister, cabinet and MPs should be defined in law. This would include clear job descriptions so that they can be held accountable. Too often recently prime ministers have abused their powers. Without a written constitution, prime ministers are pretty much free to do whatever comes into their heads.
The ministerial code should also be placed on a statutory footing. This would set out standards of behaviour and conduct that, if breached, would lead to disciplinary measures or dismissal. There are currently measures in place to discipline MPs, but ministers and the prime minister can apparently get away with awarding lucrative public contracts to friends and be fined by the police for partying while the rest of us are bound to stay in isolation.
Historically, the royal prerogative has only been exercised by the monarch but, increasingly, this has been purloined by the prime minister and the executive. We need clear legislation that sets out what powers exist and the circumstances in which they may be used.
Put parliament back in the driving seat
Parliament is the heart of our democracy and it needs to work better. Currently, the prime minister can tell parliament what to do and when, leaving it only a few days in which to control its own debates. Parliament should be able to control its own timetable. Parliament should also vote on the prime minister, who would no longer be anointed by the monarch. This already happens in Scotland, and it should be the case for the UK.
One of the commission’s most important recommended options is for parliament to have increased powers of scrutiny of legislation. Too often, legislation is announced with no public consultation in the form of green or white papers, but is simply handed to parliament, where it goes through hardly any scrutiny or chance of amendment in the Commons, and only receives scrutiny in the Lords. In skeleton (or ‘framework’) bills, the government sets out only broad principles but leaves the details to be filled in later by ministers.
The government is also increasingly using bizarrely anachronistic ‘Henry VIII’ clauses that give ministers carte blanche to amend or do as they wish. These powers should be severely restricted as they are more in line with an autocracy than a democracy.
Strengthen cabinet independence and committee accountability
Previous governments have used the cabinet to discuss policy and the direction of travel of the government. In recent years, the cabinet has become little more than a cipher for the prime minister to rubber stamp what he, or she, intends to do. One idea to be considered would be for parliament to approve cabinet appointments, thereby giving them greater autonomy.
One part of our democracy that does work well is the committee system. Committees that mirror government departments are cross-party, with some being chaired by Conservative and some by Labour MPs. These could be strengthened even more, for example by requiring every secretary of state to present a plan every year, including their budget, and to come before their respective committee regularly to explain how this is being implemented and what has changed.
A pressing need for reform
I am an historian by training and a Cromwellian by emotion. When he was chosen as lord protector, Oliver Cromwell introduced an instrument of government that set out the limits of his powers and his relationship to parliament. It is unlikely that our country will have a full written constitution in the near future, but a statute setting out the principles of our democratic structure, protections for our human rights and civil liberties and the limits of executive power would go a long way to making things better.
These ideas were drawn from looking at what other experts and academics have written, and the commission’s own discussions. They are just some options for reform for a future government. Some things do need to be done as our democracy is under threat, it hangs in the air by a thread, with public confidence shattered and resentful. Change must come.







