At the Labour Party conference, Burnham revealed his plan to fund a new NHS-style National Care Service.
In a moving speech, Burnham announced his intention to fund this by scrapping one of the three elements of the state pension triple lock. Introduced under former chancellor George Osborne, the policy guarantees annual increases in the state pension based on whichever is highest: 2.5%, inflation, or the percentage increase of average earnings. From 2030, this will become an annual ‘double lock’, whereby state pension will increase by inflation or 2.5%, whichever is higher.
Burnham’s announcement was met by rapturous applause at the conference but has already generated some scepticism amongst economists.
Deputy Director of the Institute for Fiscal Studies, Jonathon Cribb, has said that the ‘ratchet’ element of the triple lock, that, in the long run, state pensions will be permanently higher relative to the average earnings, has been removed. The reform offers a more sustainable progression, whereby the state pension will temporarily rise above average earnings growth before falling in line. However, this would not be enough to fund universal social care in the next parliament.
Questions over cost
Sarah Woolnough, chief executive of The King’s Fund, has said that “many genuine questions remain about how these reforms will work in practice and how much it will cost”.
While Burnham’s announcement has been well received, critics do have a point. Further information is needed to demonstrate how the reforms could be made affordable.
According to the government’s calculations, changing the triple lock in this way will save £15bn a year by the end of the 2030s. However, it has been estimated by the Health Foundation that an NHS-style social care system could cost more than £18bn a year by 2035.
Aside from this £3bn discrepancy, the government will need to make immediate investment to get a National Care Service off the ground. So, if adjusting the triple lock alone won’t balance the books, where will the money come from?
The choices facing the government
The government has already restricted its policy options by announcing that the service will be ‘fully funded and not through borrowing’. That leaves two main alternatives: cutting existing government spending or raising taxes.
It is possible that Baroness Casey, who has been tasked with undertaking an independent commission into funding a National Care Service, may emulate international social care funding models.
In Sweden, elderly care is largely funded by municipal taxes and government grants, with healthcare costs paid by the elderly themselves subsidised by the state.
However, Germany’s long-term care insurance system is funded by mandatory contributions from all employees, who pay between 3.05% and 3.3% of their salary into the scheme.
Casey may also take inspiration from Burnham’s predecessors, as both Gordon Brown and Jeremy Corbyn sought to reform social care.
Building political support
Public opinion appears to be on Burnham’s side. A YouGov poll has shown that the proposed service is popular, with 74% of Britons saying they support introducing it while only 11% say they would be opposed.
Across the political spectrum however, it has drawn a more mixed reaction. While there is a broad agreement on the need for social care reform, parties remain divided over how it should be funded. To build consensus, Burnham will need to convince the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats to abandon their historic commitment to the triple lock.
How Burnham funds a new National Care Service will make or break his premiership. It will determine how he is perceived by the electorate and his ability to build cross-party support. Only time will tell whether Burnham’s political gamble flies or falters, but fortune favours the brave.
More from Lucca Di Virgilio

What happens when the media itself becomes part of the problem? Who holds it to account? 14 years after the Leveson Inquiry reported its findings, has anything really changed? And how can we build something better?
Join Bylines Network on Wednesday 21 October, for a vital conversation about the media Britain needs — and what it will take to get there.
The event will conclude with a live audience Q&A.







