• Contact
  • About
  • Authors
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
Yorkshire Bylines
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Home Affairs
    • Transport
    • World
    Johnson and Macron

    Mais oui, mon ami: Johnson and Macron display ‘le bromance’ and discuss a European Political Community

    Sinn Fein Vice President Michelle O'Neill, right, and Sinn Féin President Mary Lou McDonald at the RDS in Dublin

    Northern Ireland Protocol Bill: a hopeless case and a dangerous one?

    SAY NO TO PUTIN

    War and no peace: Putin’s war with Ukraine threatens us all

    Prime minister PMQ prep

    Brexit isn’t working – something we can all agree on

    The small number of trees shows that even the high uplands of the Dales was a woodland environment. Much has been nibbled down to the ground by heavy populations of sheep. Photo by Andy Brown

    Government policies destroying upland Yorkshire farming with no regard for the land or our health

    schools bill

    Johnson’s education power grab: from ‘liberation’ to dictatorship in one generation

    Emmanuel Macron

    French parliamentary elections 2022: shockwaves across the Channel

    Rail strikes

    Millions affected by biggest rail strike action in 30 years

    cost of living march london

    Trade union movement marches to demand better

    Trending Tags

    • Johnson
    • Coronavirus
    • Labour
    • Starmer
    • Northern Ireland protocol
    • Brexit
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Home Affairs
    • Transport
    • World
  • Politics
  • Opinion
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Culture
    • Dance
    • Food
    • Music
    • Poetry
    • Recipes
    • Sport
    Nostell Priory, Wakefield

    Glastonbury? What’s Glastonbury? When the music world came to Wakefield

    Headingley Cricket Stadium

    A view from the Roses match: is everything ‘rosey’ in English cricket?

    Bettys' Fat Rascals

    Scallywags, scoundrels and rascals abound in Yorkshire (we do like our scones)

    'Woke' beliefs

    Woke and proud: Compassion must never be allowed to go out of fashion

    Eurovision 2022 stage - photo by Michael Doherty on Wikimedia Commons licensed by CC BY-SA 4.0

    What does Ukraine’s Eurovision win tell us about the politics of solidarity?

    Red Ladder

    Climbing the Red Ladder – bringing theatre to the community

    Kaiser Chiefs in Doncaster

    Kaiser Chiefs never miss a beat in Doncaster

    Bradford Council leader Councillor Susan Hinchcliffe, second from right, is joined by Keighley Creative representatives, from left, Georgina Webster, Jan Smithies and Gemma Hobbs.

    Bradford announced as City of Culture 2025

    Queen cakes fit for a Queen

    Queen Cakes fit for the Queen’s Platinum Jubilee

    • Food
    • Music
    • Poetry
    • Sport
  • Business
    • All
    • Economy
    • Technology
    • Trade
    Freya Osment from Northern Gas Networks

    International Women in Engineering Day 2022

    Rail strikes

    Millions affected by biggest rail strike action in 30 years

    conservative party

    The Conservative Party: fiscally irresponsible and ideologically incapable of addressing the current crises

    Yorkshire cows

    British farmers are being offered a lump sum payment to leave the industry – but at what cost to agriculture?

    cost-of-living-crisis-in-voluntary-sector

    Cost-of-living crisis looming for the voluntary sector

    Money on the floor - £20 notes

    The huge cost of Brexit is being seriously understated

    Financial problems

    Surge in bad debt and late payments indicate mounting business distress in Yorkshire

    An evening photo tour of Drax power station near Selby, North Yorkshire, with excellent light towards sunset.

    Winter blackouts and rationing for six million homes as government plans for disruption to energy supply

    Jar with money cascading out of it

    Boosterism doesn’t put food on the table

    Trending Tags

      • Economy
      • Technology
      • Trade
    • Region
    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • News
      • All
      • Brexit
      • Education
      • Environment
      • Health
      • Home Affairs
      • Transport
      • World
      Johnson and Macron

      Mais oui, mon ami: Johnson and Macron display ‘le bromance’ and discuss a European Political Community

      Sinn Fein Vice President Michelle O'Neill, right, and Sinn Féin President Mary Lou McDonald at the RDS in Dublin

      Northern Ireland Protocol Bill: a hopeless case and a dangerous one?

      SAY NO TO PUTIN

      War and no peace: Putin’s war with Ukraine threatens us all

      Prime minister PMQ prep

      Brexit isn’t working – something we can all agree on

      The small number of trees shows that even the high uplands of the Dales was a woodland environment. Much has been nibbled down to the ground by heavy populations of sheep. Photo by Andy Brown

      Government policies destroying upland Yorkshire farming with no regard for the land or our health

      schools bill

      Johnson’s education power grab: from ‘liberation’ to dictatorship in one generation

      Emmanuel Macron

      French parliamentary elections 2022: shockwaves across the Channel

      Rail strikes

      Millions affected by biggest rail strike action in 30 years

      cost of living march london

      Trade union movement marches to demand better

      Trending Tags

      • Johnson
      • Coronavirus
      • Labour
      • Starmer
      • Northern Ireland protocol
      • Brexit
      • Culture
      • Education
      • Environment
      • Home Affairs
      • Transport
      • World
    • Politics
    • Opinion
    • Lifestyle
      • All
      • Culture
      • Dance
      • Food
      • Music
      • Poetry
      • Recipes
      • Sport
      Nostell Priory, Wakefield

      Glastonbury? What’s Glastonbury? When the music world came to Wakefield

      Headingley Cricket Stadium

      A view from the Roses match: is everything ‘rosey’ in English cricket?

      Bettys' Fat Rascals

      Scallywags, scoundrels and rascals abound in Yorkshire (we do like our scones)

      'Woke' beliefs

      Woke and proud: Compassion must never be allowed to go out of fashion

      Eurovision 2022 stage - photo by Michael Doherty on Wikimedia Commons licensed by CC BY-SA 4.0

      What does Ukraine’s Eurovision win tell us about the politics of solidarity?

      Red Ladder

      Climbing the Red Ladder – bringing theatre to the community

      Kaiser Chiefs in Doncaster

      Kaiser Chiefs never miss a beat in Doncaster

      Bradford Council leader Councillor Susan Hinchcliffe, second from right, is joined by Keighley Creative representatives, from left, Georgina Webster, Jan Smithies and Gemma Hobbs.

      Bradford announced as City of Culture 2025

      Queen cakes fit for a Queen

      Queen Cakes fit for the Queen’s Platinum Jubilee

      • Food
      • Music
      • Poetry
      • Sport
    • Business
      • All
      • Economy
      • Technology
      • Trade
      Freya Osment from Northern Gas Networks

      International Women in Engineering Day 2022

      Rail strikes

      Millions affected by biggest rail strike action in 30 years

      conservative party

      The Conservative Party: fiscally irresponsible and ideologically incapable of addressing the current crises

      Yorkshire cows

      British farmers are being offered a lump sum payment to leave the industry – but at what cost to agriculture?

      cost-of-living-crisis-in-voluntary-sector

      Cost-of-living crisis looming for the voluntary sector

      Money on the floor - £20 notes

      The huge cost of Brexit is being seriously understated

      Financial problems

      Surge in bad debt and late payments indicate mounting business distress in Yorkshire

      An evening photo tour of Drax power station near Selby, North Yorkshire, with excellent light towards sunset.

      Winter blackouts and rationing for six million homes as government plans for disruption to energy supply

      Jar with money cascading out of it

      Boosterism doesn’t put food on the table

      Trending Tags

        • Economy
        • Technology
        • Trade
      • Region
      No Result
      View All Result
      Yorkshire Bylines
      No Result
      View All Result
      Home Politics

      Book review: Why we get the wrong politicians, by Isabel Hardman

      Why we get the wrong politicians is an award winning book that gives insight on how the government and MPs avoid scrutiny when passing legislation and bills

      John ColebyJohn Cole
      11-08-2021 07:18
      in Politics
      Cover of Isabella Hardman's "Why we get the wrong politicians"

      Cover of Isabella Hardman's "Why we get the wrong politicians"

      46
      VIEWS
      Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
      ADVERTISEMENT

      Nigel Evans is a Conservative MP who was also a deputy speaker in the Commons. This latter position meant that he didn’t vote on various bills that passed through the Commons, such as the legal aid, sentencing and punishment of offenders (LASPO) bill. And he soon became badly caught out by the bill, once enacted.

      Evans was charged with rape and serious sexual assaults and stood trial. He was acquitted on all charges but then found himself faced with a £130,000 legal bill. In earlier times his expenses would have been covered by legal aid, but LASPO had (as the coalition government had intended) restricted access to legal aid and Evans now found himself on the wrong end of the new legislation.

      Scrutiny, or non-scrutiny, of legislation

      Not just the legal profession but informed commentators generally were highly critical of LASPO (it has subsequently been amended). In Why we get the wrong politicians, Isabel Hardman explains that “it is still a bad law because it is doing what ministers promised it wouldn’t”. And the fault lies with poor parliamentary scrutiny.

      A major theme of this insightful book is that the House of Commons is very poor at scrutinising legislation. Before a bill becomes law, it is twice debated in the Commons. In between, the bill goes to one of the bill committees, which go through the proposal line by line. Whilst MPs from various parties make up these bill committees, there is always a government majority and government members are ‘whipped’ to do as the government tells them.

      The work of these bill committees is an exercise in futility and MPs have been known to use their time there to write Christmas cards or answer constituents’ letters. Being put on a bill committee is viewed as punishment handed out by party whips.

      MPs avoid scrutiny responsibilities

      One MP confided to Hardman: “Scrutiny on legislation here is very bad; the whole thing is theatre.” Prior to being elected a Labour MP, Wes Streeting had been in favour of reform of the House of Lords, making it more democratic. As an MP he has changed his mind, having seen poor scrutiny in the lower house. He says:

      “I think the Lords is much better for scrutiny than the Commons. Patronage [in the Commons] is so strong and the executive dominates. We don’t really have time to look at legislation. We don’t take ourselves seriously as legislators.”

      Apart from LASPO, Hardman lists six other areas where scrutiny of legislation failed and fundamental problems emerged only subsequently. These include the switch to the community charge (poll tax) under Margaret Thatcher, and the Dangerous Dogs Act, described by Hardman as “ineffective legislation rushed through in order to be seen to be doing something”.

      The executive (government) controls business in the legislature (Commons) and Hardman gives examples of both Conservative and Labour administrations acting with hubristic arrogance. In 2017, the fire at Grenfell Tower claimed over 70 lives. A previous fire in 2009 at Lakanal House had resulted in six deaths, and it is acknowledged that there were important lessons to learn. Backbenchers on the all-party group on fire safety wrote to the government in 2014 expressing concern that not enough was being done. But their report was batted away by government. The tragedy of Grenfell was a consequence.

      Separation of powers

      Many would say the problem of poor scrutiny in the UK arises because we do not have a separation of powers. In the US, Congress constitutes the legislature and the president and cabinet constitute the executive. In the UK by contrast, the executive is drawn from members of the Commons and to a lesser extent the Lords.

      Between 15 percent and 20 percent of MPs are on the government payroll, and most have extra income and certainly prestige. All 650 MPs are elected primarily as legislators, but for the more ambitious the temptation (well described by Hardman) is to seek to become a minister – or beyond. For the ambitious, scrutiny is a chore to be avoided.

      Would the UK do better to move to a constitution that separated out the executive from the legislature? The arguments in favour are strong, but Hardman produces counter-arguments that give pause for thought. As an alternative, Hardman suggests a change that would see bill committees merged with the existing crop of select committees.

      Each select committees covers a specific subject area, such as education or health and social care. These committees have significantly more prestige than the bill committees. Membership of select committees is determined by MPs voting among themselves (rather than being appointed by whips). An established ethos means that members leave their party hats outside the meetings and, in contrast to bill committees, they are served by a small staff.

      Having proposed legislation scrutinised by the ‘Hardman hybrid’ would mean that experts in that area, who are not under pressure from the whips, would give a bill a much more thorough review.

      How are party candidates selected?

      Hardman begins her book by looking at how parties select their candidates prior to an election – and how people put themselves forward for selection. It is a shocking fact that if you wish to engage in a proper fight for a seat in parliament, it’s going to cost you money. Research shows that, even ignoring any loss of income, the average cost to a candidate personally is between £20,000 and £25,000. And in any one constituency, there is only ever one winner.

      Hardman interviews candidates who fought hard for months but came up short. For many of those who failed, it was an incredibly hard knock to take. Not untypically, one woman admitted to crying every day for the next three months. Elections are tough and whilst you might have been a very diligent MP seeking re-election, if the swing is against your party nationally you are out on your ear.

      In the 1950s, the Conservative Party boasted 2.8 million members. Today that number is 140,000, with a high proportion of them being retired and with a political philosophy drawn from The Daily Telegraph and the Daily Mail. In selecting a Tory candidate, there is an inbuilt bias in favour of straight men who are happily married with a family, in their early forties, and wear a suit. Misogyny rears its head here and in other parties. With the financial hurdle mentioned above, our system ends up drawing candidates from too narrow a pool.

      Your personal life

      There are other disincentives to offering yourself as candidate. Why put yourself forward, when this is likely to lead to close scrutiny of your social media accounts? Even if you’ve not been previously indiscreet, the trolls will get you as you progress your campaign, and more so if you enter parliament. “No wonder”, comments Hardman, “parliament does not look like the rest of the UK”.

      Chapter 5 is headed ‘Getting Caught’ and Chapter 6 ‘Getting Ill’. In the former, the writer takes us through the expenses scandal of 2009 and the number of illicit sexual affairs that take place in Westminster. ‘Getting Ill’ deals with the twin troubles of alcohol addiction and the pressures that lead to mental illness. A wise person potentially considering candidacy might well be put off by the huge damage life at Westminster can do a spouse and their family life.

      Hardman deserves credit for dealing with these issues with great sensitivity and compassion. She has interviewed an impressive number of MPs, both on and off the record. It is not that she lightly dismisses failures, but rather that with her wide understanding of Westminster she is able to contextualise.

      Constituency surgeries and casework

      In ‘Getting Out’, Hardman records her visits with sitting MPs to their constituency surgeries. It is perhaps testimony to her reputation within parliament that this includes sitting in on a surgery with David Cameron. One constituent visiting Cameron was a solicitor who was able to explain in detail the damage that LASPO was causing. Only in his surgery did the scales fall from Cameron’s eyes and the task began to rectify the Act.

      All visits to surgeries carried the same story – of constituents whose lives were being badly messed up because of the unintended consequences of badly drafted legislation. After surgeries, MPs spend an inordinate amount of time trying to correct the costly errors resulting from poorly scrutinised legislation. Hence Hardman’s contention that better scrutiny would head off damage in the first place.

      Hardman recalls her various meetings with Jo Cox and how much the MP for Batley and Spen impressed her as a force for good. Our MPs often pay a high price for us – none more so than Jo.

      The impact of over-centralisation

      It’s worth noting that MPs devote a significant proportion of their time to constituency casework, meaning that other activities are crowded out. Hardman points out that in the 1950s it was not uncommon for MPs to visit their constituency only once per month if that. Today, MPs have become glorified factotum social workers.

      Hardman might have made the point that if government in the UK had not become so over-centralised then some of the casework coming to MPs might be easily dealt with at local government level.

      Can I recommend this book? Unhesitatingly. It has been meticulously researched and is wide ranging. It is thoughtful and practical in its suggestions. But perhaps above all, it is its humanity.

      Tags: Democracy
      ADVERTISEMENT
      Previous Post

      Bradford University sells historic mansion

      Next Post

      Is presenteeism the new battlefront in the right’s culture wars?

      John Cole

      John Cole

      John has had two careers – firstly teaching economics and secondly as a district councillor on Bradford Council. A liberal since 6th form, he has twice been a parliamentary candidate for the Liberal Democrats. John is a keen internationalist and writer of letters - over the years he has sent in nearly two hundred to the Yorkshire Post. He enjoys singing, playing bridge and gardening.

      Related Posts

      Johnson and Macron
      Politics

      Mais oui, mon ami: Johnson and Macron display ‘le bromance’ and discuss a European Political Community

      byProfessor Juliet Lodge
      29 June 2022
      Sinn Fein Vice President Michelle O'Neill, right, and Sinn Féin President Mary Lou McDonald at the RDS in Dublin
      Brexit

      Northern Ireland Protocol Bill: a hopeless case and a dangerous one?

      byAnthony Robinson
      29 June 2022
      Death Star
      Politics

      Wakefield by-election journal: volume 4 (tech, lies and video crews on the trail of Wakefield Man)

      byJimmy Andrex
      28 June 2022
      boris johnson clown poster
      Politics

      Johnson, Nixon and dangerous duplicity: half a century of ‘gate’ scandals

      byDr Pam Jarvis
      28 June 2022
      Conservative Party Meeting
      Politics

      Hypocrisy, desperation and excuses: Conservative Party clutch at straws over by-election losses

      bySue Wilson MBE
      27 June 2022
      Next Post
      Working from home, image by Mikey Harris on Unsplash

      Is presenteeism the new battlefront in the right’s culture wars?

      Want to support us?

      Can you help Yorkshire Bylines to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?  

      DONATE

      Sign up to our newsletter

      If you would like to receive the Yorkshire Bylines regular newsletter, straight talking direct to your inbox, click the button below.

      NEWSLETTER

      LATEST

      Johnson and Macron

      Mais oui, mon ami: Johnson and Macron display ‘le bromance’ and discuss a European Political Community

      29 June 2022
      Sinn Fein Vice President Michelle O'Neill, right, and Sinn Féin President Mary Lou McDonald at the RDS in Dublin

      Northern Ireland Protocol Bill: a hopeless case and a dangerous one?

      29 June 2022
      SAY NO TO PUTIN

      War and no peace: Putin’s war with Ukraine threatens us all

      29 June 2022
      Death Star

      Wakefield by-election journal: volume 4 (tech, lies and video crews on the trail of Wakefield Man)

      28 June 2022

      MOST READ

      Prime minister PMQ prep

      Brexit isn’t working – something we can all agree on

      28 June 2022
      Sinn Fein Vice President Michelle O'Neill, right, and Sinn Féin President Mary Lou McDonald at the RDS in Dublin

      Northern Ireland Protocol Bill: a hopeless case and a dangerous one?

      29 June 2022
      Photo credit Robert Sharp / englishpenLicensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license.

      The Davis Downside Dossier

      1 January 2021
      boris johnson clown poster

      Johnson, Nixon and dangerous duplicity: half a century of ‘gate’ scandals

      28 June 2022

      BROWSE BY TAGS

      antivaxxers Charity Climate change Coronavirus Cost of living Creative industries Crime Cummings Democracy Devolution Equality Farming Fishing History Immigration Johnson Journalism Labour Mental health NHS Northern Ireland protocol Pollution Poverty PPE Starmer Travel Ukraine
      Yorkshire Bylines

      Yorkshire Bylines is a regional online newspaper that supports citizen journalism. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Yorkshire and beyond.

      Learn more about us

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Contact
      • About
      • Letters
      • Donate
      • Privacy
      • Bylines network
      • Shop

      © 2022 Yorkshire Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • News
        • Brexit
        • Education
        • Environment
        • Health
        • Home Affairs
        • Transport
        • World
      • Politics
      • Opinion
      • Lifestyle
        • Culture
        • Dance
        • Food
        • Music
        • Poetry
        • Recipes
        • Sport
      • Business
        • Economy
        • Technology
        • Trade
      • Donate
      • The Compendium of Cabinet Codebreakers
      • The Davis Downside Dossier
      • The Digby Jones Index
      • Newsletter sign up
      • Cartoons by Stan
      • Authors

      © 2022 Yorkshire Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password?

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In