• Contact
  • About
  • Authors
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
Yorkshire Bylines
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Home Affairs
    • Transport
    • World
    Image of a baby deer

    Steer clear of baby deer!

    RAF Linton

    RAF Linton to house asylum seekers: what we know so far

    Prime Minister Johnson meets with Mary Lou McDonald of Sinn Fein

    Johnson returns from his Belfast train crash empty handed

    It began as a mistake

    Made a mistake? Simple: just deny it ever happened and make it again

    Working from home cartoon

    Working from home under attack by out-of-touch and out-of-date government

    image of carer and patient

    Government fails to support unpaid carers

    Image of oil rig

    Oil sticks: what’s behind the rising price of oil?

    Cartoon by Stan

    Refugees: what next after the Nationality and Borders Act?

    FOI request denied

    Freedom of information or denial of information?

    Trending Tags

    • Johnson
    • Coronavirus
    • Labour
    • Starmer
    • NI Protocol
    • Brexit
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Home Affairs
    • Transport
    • World
  • Politics
  • Opinion
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Culture
    • Dance
    • Food
    • Music
    • Poetry
    • Recipes
    • Sport
    Photo courtesy of the JORVIK Centre

    JORVIK Viking festival

    Image of Cragg Vale

    Norky’s Ramblings: a WARTS ramble in Cragg Vale

    Image of 'no racism' at cricket match

    Condoning racism in English cricket comes at a price: £50,000 to be exact

    Debbie Kurup as Star (centre) in The Cher Show, credit Pamela Raith

    The Cher Show: a truly believable show

    image of nadine dorries

    Dorries isn’t joking! Privatising Channel 4 will protect public service broadcasting

    Wild Fell by Lee Schofield

    Book Review: Wild Fell – Fighting for Nature on a Lake District Hill Farm, by Lee Schofield

    Coat of arms of Bulgaria

    Happy St George’s Day in Bulgaria!

    Chicken crossing the road

    Carry on spaffing: why did the chicken cross the road?

    Rotherham

    William Cowen and Yorkshire’s Changing Landscapes

    • Food
    • Music
    • Poetry
    • Sport
  • Business
    • All
    • Economy
    • Technology
    • Trade
    Food bank packing at the Cornerstone Community Centre in Newcastle-under-Lyme, by Staffs Live on Flikr

    Sooner rather than later – why the poorest households need help now

    Constructing houses

    Trouble in Happy Valley: Calderdale Council struggles to agree its local plan

    Cost of living crisis

    A government that’s out of touch and out of ideas

    Cost of living - a house, a piggy bank and a magnifying glass

    Cost-of-living crisis likely to escalate due to rising global consumption

    Driverless car

    How safe are driverless cars?

    Port of Dover, Eastern Docks, Customs Control

    Brexit border checks: better never than late?

    no money to spare

    Levelling down in North Yorkshire: local government reorganisation delivers greater Conservative control but no new money

    Unite the Union flags

    Workers at major housing association in Yorkshire considering strike action after ‘insulting’ pay offer

    Smart meter

    22 million people in the UK having to pay over 50 percent more for energy, as the price cap rises

    Trending Tags

      • Economy
      • Technology
      • Trade
    • Region
    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • News
      • All
      • Brexit
      • Education
      • Environment
      • Health
      • Home Affairs
      • Transport
      • World
      Image of a baby deer

      Steer clear of baby deer!

      RAF Linton

      RAF Linton to house asylum seekers: what we know so far

      Prime Minister Johnson meets with Mary Lou McDonald of Sinn Fein

      Johnson returns from his Belfast train crash empty handed

      It began as a mistake

      Made a mistake? Simple: just deny it ever happened and make it again

      Working from home cartoon

      Working from home under attack by out-of-touch and out-of-date government

      image of carer and patient

      Government fails to support unpaid carers

      Image of oil rig

      Oil sticks: what’s behind the rising price of oil?

      Cartoon by Stan

      Refugees: what next after the Nationality and Borders Act?

      FOI request denied

      Freedom of information or denial of information?

      Trending Tags

      • Johnson
      • Coronavirus
      • Labour
      • Starmer
      • NI Protocol
      • Brexit
      • Culture
      • Education
      • Environment
      • Home Affairs
      • Transport
      • World
    • Politics
    • Opinion
    • Lifestyle
      • All
      • Culture
      • Dance
      • Food
      • Music
      • Poetry
      • Recipes
      • Sport
      Photo courtesy of the JORVIK Centre

      JORVIK Viking festival

      Image of Cragg Vale

      Norky’s Ramblings: a WARTS ramble in Cragg Vale

      Image of 'no racism' at cricket match

      Condoning racism in English cricket comes at a price: £50,000 to be exact

      Debbie Kurup as Star (centre) in The Cher Show, credit Pamela Raith

      The Cher Show: a truly believable show

      image of nadine dorries

      Dorries isn’t joking! Privatising Channel 4 will protect public service broadcasting

      Wild Fell by Lee Schofield

      Book Review: Wild Fell – Fighting for Nature on a Lake District Hill Farm, by Lee Schofield

      Coat of arms of Bulgaria

      Happy St George’s Day in Bulgaria!

      Chicken crossing the road

      Carry on spaffing: why did the chicken cross the road?

      Rotherham

      William Cowen and Yorkshire’s Changing Landscapes

      • Food
      • Music
      • Poetry
      • Sport
    • Business
      • All
      • Economy
      • Technology
      • Trade
      Food bank packing at the Cornerstone Community Centre in Newcastle-under-Lyme, by Staffs Live on Flikr

      Sooner rather than later – why the poorest households need help now

      Constructing houses

      Trouble in Happy Valley: Calderdale Council struggles to agree its local plan

      Cost of living crisis

      A government that’s out of touch and out of ideas

      Cost of living - a house, a piggy bank and a magnifying glass

      Cost-of-living crisis likely to escalate due to rising global consumption

      Driverless car

      How safe are driverless cars?

      Port of Dover, Eastern Docks, Customs Control

      Brexit border checks: better never than late?

      no money to spare

      Levelling down in North Yorkshire: local government reorganisation delivers greater Conservative control but no new money

      Unite the Union flags

      Workers at major housing association in Yorkshire considering strike action after ‘insulting’ pay offer

      Smart meter

      22 million people in the UK having to pay over 50 percent more for energy, as the price cap rises

      Trending Tags

        • Economy
        • Technology
        • Trade
      • Region
      No Result
      View All Result
      Yorkshire Bylines
      No Result
      View All Result
      Home Opinion

      Re-enactivism and monument wars

      As a historian and art historian, I do not join the love-in for the Colston Four. Tearing down the statue only harms the art.

      Dr M M GilchristbyDr M M Gilchrist
      14-01-2022 12:04
      in Opinion
      Colston statue; RedSquirrel, CC BY-SA 4.0 , via Wikimedia Commons

      Colston statue; RedSquirrel, CC BY-SA 4.0 , via Wikimedia Commons

      185
      VIEWS
      Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
      ADVERTISEMENT

      It is naïve to compare their actions to the toppling of Saddam Hussein’s statue in Iraq, or the fall of the Berlin Wall – reactions to present-day oppressions directly experienced by those involved. The Colston case is what Bristol Mayor Marvin Rees has called ‘performance activism’. I call it ‘re-enactivism’, role-playing a historical battle already won. An anti-slavery protest in 1821 would have had a point: but in 2021?

      The word ‘vandalism’, to describe the deliberate destruction of artworks, was coined during the French Revolution by Henri Grégoire, an anti-slavery campaigner and priest. I was reminded of an incident in Arras in the 1990s, after the Bicentenary of the Revolution. Vandals dressed up as jeunesse dorée –Royalist dandies of the 1790s – beheaded figures on a monument to the Rosati (a local literary society), probably because the prominent Revolutionary Maximilien Robespierre had been a member. They were never caught. The sculptures have since been restored. But it was as pointless as dramatic and damaging: a protest for a cause two centuries in the past.

      Rosati Memorial (restored)

      Robespierre: controversial revolutionary

      Arras is a good place to look at contested histories and controversial monuments. Plans are now finally underway in Arras to make Robespierre’s House into a museum and study centre on the French Revolution. Siblings Maximilien, Charlotte and Augustin Robespierre rented a town-house for a few years in the late 1780s. The building spent much of 20th century as a typing school – losing many of its period features – and was only acquired by the council in the 1980s.

      Disputes over commemorating Robespierre (like Grégoire, also an opponent of slavery) go back many years. The Counter-Reformation left the town – once part of the Spanish Netherlands – with a strong traditionalist Catholic component. As a border territory, threatened with invasion during the Revolutionary wars, it saw harsh local repression under Joseph Le Bon. A guillotine operated in the Place du Théâtre. After the coup of Thermidor, Year 2 (July 1794), Maximilien Robespierre was made a convenient scapegoat locally as well as nationally.

      The fiercest memorial battles arose during the reconstruction of Arras after the First World War, as Steven Kaplan describes in Farewell, Revolution: Disputed Legacies, France 1789/1989. The Renaissance town hall had been smashed to rubble, but rose again. The squares and streets were pieced back together, new monuments planned. The left-wing mayor proposed a bust of Robespierre.

      Robespierre’s House

      Jeanne d’Arc: Catholic nationalist icon

      The religious right retaliated by demanding a memorial to Jeanne d’Arc, who was said to have been briefly imprisoned by the Burgundians in the keep in 1430. Her cult is closely associated with right-wing nationalism, even monarchism. It took off in 19th century, especially after the Prussians seized Alsace and Lorraine in 1871, because Jeanne had been born in Lorraine (then part of the Holy Roman Empire). She was beatified in 1909 and promoted as a patriotic icon in World War I, in which France aimed to retake Alsace and Lorraine. Her 1920 canonisation recognised her wartime propaganda role and served the Vatican’s fightback against the French Republic’s laïcité.

      However, she presents another problem in Arras. She was a prisoner there because Arras was not then in France, but in the Burgundian State, allied to England in the 100 Years War. This later became the Spanish Netherlands, from which Arras was taken by France in the Thirty Years’ War (and formally ceded in 1659). Commemorating a French national heroine in a town which was not part of France in her time – indeed, where she was an enemy combatant – could be seen as rubbing Arrageois noses in their own annexation, all the more perplexing when driven by locals.

      Robespierre and Jeanne d’Arc: commemorating opposites

      Despite stunts such as mock-guillotines, the pouring of red paint in the street by Royalists, and vandalism against a commemorative plaque on his house, Robespierre got a rather chunky Art Deco bust by Marius Léon Cladel, a sculptor from a pro-Communard (and part-Jewish) literary family, in 1933. It is kept inside the rebuilt Hôtel de Ville, partly for its safety and partly because the marble used is not weatherproof, although there are casts of it in his house and also at the Lycée Robespierre. Jeanne, meanwhile, has a much larger bronze and stone monument outside the Cathedral of Saint-Vaast. It is by Maxime Réal del Sarte, a right-wing Catholic, a supporter of the Orléanist monarchist cause and of L’Action Française, who had lost an arm in the First World War.

      Place de la Sorbonne Photo credit: M M Gilchrist
      Politics

      Isolating the imagination: the decline of languages

      byDr M M Gilchrist
      20 August 2020
      Image of a baby deer
      Environment

      Steer clear of baby deer!

      byYorkshire Bylines
      18 May 2022
      RAF Linton
      Home Affairs

      RAF Linton to house asylum seekers: what we know so far

      byDr Stella Perrott
      18 May 2022
      Indyref march
      Politics

      SNP success in local government elections heralds second Scottish independence referendum

      byMartin Roche
      17 May 2022
      Photo courtesy of the JORVIK Centre
      Culture

      JORVIK Viking festival

      byKerry Pearson
      17 May 2022

      Art matters

      The idea that an artwork deserves protection only if you ‘approve of’ its subject is troubling. Who decides? Many Renaissance and Baroque rulers would be in trouble. I have a deep antipathy towards Peter I and his war-mongering, repressive autocracy; but the world would be poorer without Falconet and Collot’s Bronze Horseman, and the literature (by Pushkin and Bely, among others) it has inspired. Also, a statue or portrait is not a witch’s poppet: damaging or destroying it cannot harm its subject, living or dead. It harms only the work of art.

      And what about the artist? John Cassidy (1860–1939), Colston’s Irish-born sculptor, whose Manchester grave carries the epitaph ‘His hands fashioned the beauty he saw’, has been erased from the discussion. His other works include more radical figures: a plaque to Henry ‘Orator’ Hunt and sketches for a monument to Theobald Wolfe Tone. His Colston figure is an elegant, if generic 17th century gentleman, who could as easily be repurposed as John Evelyn or Isaac Newton, or ‘answered’ by an anti-slavery figure placed in dialogue.

      Living with competing narratives

      A mature society should be able to live with multiple and conflicting historical narratives. To applaud the vandalism of art depicting characters you dislike leaves no defence when your opponents attack those you prefer. Arras – indeed, France generally – has experienced several past iconoclasms and seems, on the whole, to have come out the other side. The southern city of Montpellier’s Place de la Révolution Française has busts of figures from rival factions, copied from 18th and 19th century originals, all now sharing the same space.

      What worries me most, though, is that young people seem more energised by this kind of re-enactivism than by the real dangers we currently face: assaults on democracy; assaults on the NHS in the face of covid; the theft of our European identity and citizenship. Tearing down 19th century statues, instead of Tufton or Downing Street, is a self-indulgent displacement activity.

      Tags: History
      ADVERTISEMENT
      Previous Post

      Why calls to release security information from Downing Street parties are misplaced

      Next Post

      French presidential candidate Eric Zemmour: another populist player

      Dr M M Gilchrist

      Dr M M Gilchrist

      Marianne is a freelance historian and art historian, who grew up in Hull and studied at St Andrews. She was Doors Open Days/European Heritage Days co-ordinator for Scotland for three years and worked as a research assistant at the University of Glasgow. She is particularly interested in the use and abuse of history in the arts. She has written and lectured on subjects ranging from the Third Crusade to French Revolutionary portraiture.

      Related Posts

      Prime Minister Boris Johnson leaves for PMQ
      Opinion

      Johnson’s last lines of defence on partygate are crumbling

      byAnthony Robinson
      6 May 2022
      Rwandan small wooden cross
      Home Affairs

      Reflecting on the message of this Rwandan cross, made from the burnt churches of Genocide 1994

      byFrances Cole
      1 May 2022
      Image of the book, 'The Semi-detached european'
      Brexit

      The Semi-detached European, by Michael Hindley: a review

      byProfessor Juliet Lodge
      25 April 2022
      Rees-Mogg lying in parliament, cartoon by Stan
      Opinion

      New bill on exemptions from legal consequences to be rushed onto the statute books in time for local elections

      byMartin Brooks
      22 April 2022
      Superman Sunak's kryptonite, cartoon by Stan
      Opinion

      How Superman Sunak made his own kryptonite

      bySam Chandler
      14 April 2022
      Next Post
      French election sign

      French presidential candidate Eric Zemmour: another populist player

      Want to support us?

      Can you help Yorkshire Bylines to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?  

      DONATE

      Sign up to our newsletter

      If you would like to receive the Yorkshire Bylines regular newsletter, straight talking direct to your inbox, click the button below.

      NEWSLETTER

      LATEST

      Image of a baby deer

      Steer clear of baby deer!

      18 May 2022
      RAF Linton

      RAF Linton to house asylum seekers: what we know so far

      18 May 2022
      Indyref march

      SNP success in local government elections heralds second Scottish independence referendum

      17 May 2022
      Photo courtesy of the JORVIK Centre

      JORVIK Viking festival

      17 May 2022

      MOST READ

      Prime Minister Johnson meets with Mary Lou McDonald of Sinn Fein

      Johnson returns from his Belfast train crash empty handed

      17 May 2022
      It began as a mistake

      Made a mistake? Simple: just deny it ever happened and make it again

      17 May 2022
      RAF Linton

      RAF Linton to house asylum seekers: what we know so far

      18 May 2022
      Photo credit Robert Sharp / englishpenLicensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license.

      The Davis Downside Dossier

      1 January 2021

      BROWSE BY TAGS

      antivaxxers Charity climate change Coronavirus Cost of living Creative industries Crime Cummings Democracy Devolution Equality Farming Fishing hgv History Immigration Johnson Journalism Labour Local Democracy Mental Health mining money NHS NI Protocol omicron Pies pollution poverty PPE Public Health Review shortage social media Starmer tax travel Ukraine Yorkshire
      Yorkshire Bylines

      Yorkshire Bylines is a regional online newspaper that supports citizen journalism. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Yorkshire and beyond.

      Learn more about us

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Contact
      • About
      • Letters
      • Donate
      • Privacy
      • Bylines network
      • Shop

      © 2022 Yorkshire Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • News
        • Brexit
        • Education
        • Environment
        • Health
        • Home Affairs
        • Transport
        • World
      • Politics
      • Opinion
      • Lifestyle
        • Culture
        • Dance
        • Food
        • Music
        • Poetry
        • Recipes
        • Sport
      • Business
        • Economy
        • Technology
        • Trade
      • Donate
      • The Compendium of Cabinet Codebreakers
      • The Davis Downside Dossier
      • The Digby Jones Index
      • Newsletter sign up
      • Cartoons by Stan
      • Authors

      © 2022 Yorkshire Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password?

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In