In 2018 Gibraltar’s chief minister, Fabian Picardo, warned the population to brace themselves for a period of “peaks and troughs” before the Brexit withdrawal agreement between the UK and EU was finalised. A year later, he referred to the political climate as “a rollercoaster that we’re all riding on, without knowing what awaits us in the future – because we are not fortune-tellers”.
Well, here we are in April 2024 and that rollercoaster has never stopped, for Gibraltar at least.
The Gibraltar Brexit deal
There was general euphoria and an almost tangible sense of relief on 31 December 2020, when Picardo announced that his government had reached an in-principle agreement with the UK and Spain: a proposed framework for a treaty on Gibraltar’s future relationship with the EU. Under the terms of this agreement, the land border which threatened to become so problematic as a result of Brexit would disappear and the external Schengen border would be moved to Gibraltar airport and port, staffed by officers from the EU Frontex force rather than Spain.
This would create an area of mutual prosperity for Gibraltar and the nearest area of Spain, called the Campo de Gibraltar. “We want to see greater prosperity become a material reality for the whole of Gibraltar and the whole of the region around us… the arrival, at the end of the Brexit storm, of a rainbow of opportunities”, as the chief minister’s statement put it.
So the question on everyone’s lips now is: where is it? Where is this treaty, the area of mutual prosperity, the abolition of the land border? Wasn’t it only supposed to take six months to complete? Why are they taking so long?
Is a Gibraltar deal close to being agreed?
Excitement mounted recently with news that a ‘top level treaty meeting’ would take place in Brussels on 12 April between Fabian Picardo, UK foreign secretary Lord Cameron, his Spanish counterpart José Manuel Albares and EU Commissioner Maroš Šefčovič, who is responsible for relations with the UK. Was this finally it? Were the seemingly endless talks finally over?
No, was the disappointing reply. The meeting had been positive and constructive. There had been progress, but there was still some work to do. Tantalisingly, the joint statement issued afterwards referred to agreement having been reached on general policy lines, including the airport, goods and mobility, all of which had been widely believed to have been major sticking points. But no details were given, and that was deliberate.
In an interview with TV channel GBC News, Picardo explained that everything he is reading in the press about these negotiations is “contrary to the reality of what’s going on” and is speculation on the part of journalism. It would not be helpful at this very late stage to move the negotiation into the media, he said. Whilst understanding that people want to know what is happening, this would not be “a useful way of getting this to the destination we all want, which is a secure and safe treaty”.
Brexit treaties are far from simple
Following that latest meeting, numerous journalists have been proclaiming that it’s about time a deal is done, that it has all taken too long and those involved should pull their finger out. Perhaps they should stop doing that and, instead, reflect on the sheer magnitude of this agreement, if indeed there is one, because it could all still fall apart, even now.
There is nothing simple about this proposed treaty, just as there was nothing simple about Brexit. It’s not a case of ‘just’ moving a border from one place to another; far more is involved and too much is at stake to rush to a conclusion. Dots have to be placed on ‘i’s, crosses put on ‘t’s. Everybody’s interests have to be safeguarded and protected, everyone’s red lines must remain firmly intact. Every possible consequence has to be considered, by all sides.
Early in the Brexit negotiations, Picardo said there was concern that they could wake up the day after it happened and realise there were things nobody had realised or thought of, because this was a unique situation. Well, this is, too.
Patience is needed
If this treaty is agreed, it will be historic: for Gibraltar, for Spain, for the EU and the UK. But Picardo has also warned that there are bound to be things in it which people won’t like, because that’s the nature of such negotiations. Also, the arrangements would be for four years and would then be subject to review. That could be another headache.
So yes, the wait has been agonising and the lack of information frustrating. The rollercoaster is still hurtling us upwards and plunging us downwards, but there is nothing any of us can do to stop it.
It is said that patience is a virtue. It may be wearing thin after all this time, but for the sake of Gibraltar and the nearby Campo area, we’re all going to have to be virtuous for a bit longer.







