Much is said these days about wellbeing, mental health and a healthy work-life balance, as part and parcel of the brave new world that is trying to embrace values. Many workplaces claim to put a high emphasis on wellbeing, but few can really demonstrate how effective they have been in reducing stress, creating happy environments, and increasing productivity as they seek to promote a ‘values-driven culture’.
Additionally, much of the language around values is used as if everyone knows what it means. And everyone must know how to get there! Surely?
This language of values and ethics is used more in our society, but we need to get to grips with the inner work that we must also do to become more human as individuals and as a whole. In Oneself as Another, the much-loved French philosopher Paul Ricoeur argued that the reason ethics has to exist is because “the other” exists.
Put simply, the key to understanding what is ethical is driven by the specific response that that ‘other’ requires. If we are by ourselves, we don’t have to consider this as much – although these days we hear much more about the relationship we have with ourselves and with our inner world.
But, for Ricoeur, ‘the other’ demands from us an ethical response just because they exist. If we buy a bus ticket or ask for help in the supermarket, it depends on the choice that ‘an–other’ makes as to whether we get the response that we need. They create the space in which what is ethical (and expected from another) is made manifest or not.
Choosing to be a certain kind of person
This applies in the opposite direction too. As much as we expect to find what we are seeking in the supermarket, once we get the response we must decide how to respond. Do we express thanks or just shrug if off with ‘it’s their job anyway’ or ‘they’re getting paid for it, so ‘they should respond to me appropriately’? Or do we decide to add that the person is ‘very kind’ and we are ‘very grateful’?
All these responses come from a decision, known in Catholic theological ethics in particular, as ‘the fundamental option’. In short, we choose to be a certain kind of person.
Less is said about the fundamental option these days, but I think its significance lies in the fact that we are in need of a reminder in today’s world that ethics is a choice. We choose to be that person. We choose to have a set of norms by which we live our lives. We choose to be good when presented with a dilemma and agonise when presented with a ‘grey area’.
Living well and for others
All these questions involve an interior dialogue with oneself – a journey within. In order to make the choice and for that decision to be truly our own, we need to engage in a profound inner dialogue. We have to go right to our core or inner sanctuary and ask ourselves a very fundamental question: ‘who do I want to be in this situation or more generally in my overall disposition towards people?’
In times gone by, society equated ethical norms with the church, religious figures or persons of authority in society, for instance. Some of us continue to believe ethics is about obedience, exclusion of certain groups, rules, norms, punishment, guilt or feelings of fear to conform. But this couldn’t be further from the truth.
The heart of the authentic moral life comes when we make that choiceto become a certain kind of person. Yes, rules and principles can provide an initial starting point regarding good and evil but the ultimate moral self is the one that has travelled beyond this basic stage.
Moving beyond the idea that what is ethical is something imposed on us or derived by others, is essential for the moral maturity that we need to embrace good character. We need to see ourselves fully empowered and ready to act for the good. We have to continuously work on ourselves in order to relate better towards others – and do what Ricoeur expressed in the phrase “live well with and for others in just institutions”.
Moving beyond obedience
The development of character is what might be called in common parlance an ‘inside job’. We have to nurture our inner world and reflect on the bigger and more complex question of ‘who am I?’ rather than ‘what rules do others want me to follow?’
Mature moral living comes from a place where we understand rules, norms and principles and respect the sources from which they may be derived. But moving beyond obedience means we can embrace a sense of being fully responsible for our decisions, the development of our own character and our own moral conscience. This takes a lot of work!
Such development requires constant reflection on what it means to be a human person in light of today’s circumstances, using knowledge and research on issues that really affect us right now, and taking responsibility for the decision we arrive at.
If we consider today all that is being said about the use of AI technology in education and health care in particular, we see clearly that some people understand what is involved and some do not. Those who do not may be relying on popular opinion and making subjective judgements about the ethics of AI. But those who are properly informed are in a better position to judge the situation – and take responsibility if things go wrong.
Self-care to find inner peace
Being a person of character means consistently engaging with the questions, ‘what is truth?’ and ‘what is truth in this situation?’ Our character virtues are built up over time – choosing consistently kind actions, for instance, makes us kind. Consistently acting for justice makes us just. It is a constant search, a continuous dialogue with the self and with tradition (especially for those who are religious) to find what needs to be done right now.
All this interior work requires something else: ways of looking after ourselves so that we fill the emptiness that pervades much of our contemporary world. We have to come to terms with our needs, to heal wounds where possible and to find ways of nurturing our inner selves. To foster peace within.
And it is this peace thatallows us to hear the voice of conscience clearly. If our inner world is chaotic, the considered reflection and discipline needed to act morally may be compromised. We act of out self-need and fear, pushing an agenda that is only for ourselves or a self-seeking clique.
Body and mind work together
The inner work we’re discussing also has a bodily aspect. Fern Cotton’s book Calm gives us a clear account of how she dealt with panic attacks that affected her whole life. And yet she was able to put on a front that all was well when, in reality, she was crumbling inside. It was only when she engaged with the effects of that bodily manifestation of fear that she learned to know herself and what she needed to feel less empty and panic-stricken. In short, she did the inner work.
It is worth noting that the search for what is true involves us also knowing ourselves from within and what affects our nervous system. We can be acting out of fear or anger and miss what the situation actually requires. We need to get to a place of calm, as Cotton suggests, to develop the key techniques that will nurture our inner life.
For some, this takes on a spiritual dimension. Religious or not, drawing on the practices of meditation, deep contemplation and silence can allow us to move beyond feeling helpless in the face of it all. Freud said we are more interesting than we thought. We just need time to consider that. And nurture it fully.
We then find there is much more to life than we thought: we are actors in a great and complex drama (see Wittgenstein, Lectures and Conversations on Aesthetics, Psychology and Religious Belief, ed. Cyril Barrett (Oxford 1970), pp. 25, 43, 51).
Values and the common good
And the drama is not yet finished, which is why we need to see the ethical life as a search rather than a done deal – archaic, static, inhibiting or impersonal.
It is an invitation to engage with the most profound aspect of life: who we are. And the more we figure that out, the readier we are to act for others and create the conditions we need as a society that wants values and the common good to be a part of how things are done – in education, business, and in all aspects of civic life.
Two decades ago, the Irish moral theologian, Vincent McNamara said in his book New Life for Old that even “the smartest philosopher […] may be an emotional mess, out of touch with their patterns and prejudices, and behaving accordingly”. This is a humbling thought. In a world where the divide between the ‘haves’ and the ‘have nots’ is every day more pronounced, it is good to remember that even apparently successful people can be a ‘mess’.
Many need to step back and ask themselves fundamental questions about how they are behaving and using power, how they understand leadership and may be relying on systems and process instead of humanity and the power of conscience to guide decision making.
Creating a safer and more secure world
This resonates with contemporary scholarship on leadership too. In Vantage Points: How to create a culture where employees thrive, author Paula Leach argues that if leadership is all about others, then authentic leadership begins in the space where we embrace what is human. For this, we must do the inner work. “The reason is because everything, even our service to others, starts with a deep and unafraid understanding of ourselves and our impact on others.”
To return to Cotton’s concluding sections of Calm, we need to realise that ‘going within’ is our best way forward. It’s not boring or outdated. It’s not for religious people only. Rather, it is for everyone who, in this complex world of chaos and alarming events that we never thought we would see again in history, cares about humanity. In short, it is about who we are as human beings.
And whether we see the answer through the lens of a religious tradition or not, we need now to attempt to create a world where we all feel more safe and secure, and empowered to live authentically and ethically, before someone in power takes those decisions for us.
But as pointed out at the beginning of this piece, that is our choice! Therefore, I leave you to consider: what path will you choose?








