• Contact
  • About
  • ISSN 3049-9720
  • Authors and editors
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
Yorkshire Bylines
Advertisement
  • Home
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Home Affairs
    • Transport
    • World
  • Politics
  • Opinion
  • Society
    • Food
    • Music
    • Poetry
    • Sport
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Science and Technology
    • Trade
  • Region
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Home Affairs
    • Transport
    • World
  • Politics
  • Opinion
  • Society
    • Food
    • Music
    • Poetry
    • Sport
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Science and Technology
    • Trade
  • Region
No Result
View All Result
Yorkshire Bylines
Home News Brexit

The search goes on for Brexit upsides

A reader sends a list of Brexit upsides for the Davis Dossier. But are they really upsides?

Anthony Robinson by Anthony Robinson
11-12-2023 16:17 - Updated on 12-12-2023 17:52
in Brexit, Home Affairs
Reading Time: 12 mins read
A A
Man with flashlight looking under the bed

image by vladdeep. Licensed by Adobe Stock (JW)

Share on Bluesky

I receive occasional emails from readers pointing out items in the news they think should be added to the dossier and I am of course always grateful for any help. However, I don’t necessarily include any that don’t appear to be genuine Brexit upsides or downsides in my opinion.

Last week an email popped into my Yorkshire Bylines inbox asking politely for me to “Please add the following to your upsides”. It wasn’t easy to spot which upsides were being referred to since the message consisted of a lot of HTML formatting code interspersed with text, making it difficult to read.

I hesitated to click on any of the links at first because I suspected it might be a phishing email, but at the bottom the sender had included a name, which matched the email address, and even a mobile phone number. So I think it is genuine, and I’m sure the sender sincerely believed he was including some upsides.

Now I don’t want to disparage any efforts to balance up the dossier, but I do think it’s worth going through the list, partly to explain why I don’t want to include them all and partly as an illustration of where we are more than seven years after the referendum and almost three years since formally exiting the EU. There is a lot of barrel-scraping here.

As far as I can work out (and it wasn’t easy), here are the ‘upsides’ of Brexit that were sent:

1. Our status has changed from being ‘in the EU’ to ‘not in the EU’

I think this may be a tautology and perhaps an obvious statement of fact rather than an upside and it could equally be thought of as a downside. It’s a bit like Theresa May and “Brexit means Brexit”.

2. We’ve changed or repealed around 1,000 pieces of retained EU legislation

I am not sure this is numerically correct, and I can’t check since the dashboard introduced by Jacob Rees-Mogg showing which EU laws have been ditched has been taken down by his successor Kemi Badenoch.

Whatever the actual number, the EU laws that have been through the culling process are largely expired, irrelevant or inconsequential and cover obscure subjects like Polish canal boats, Greenland fishing grounds and database formats for packaging waste. Others have been replaced by virtually identical UK regulations. I have written about this before here and here.What has happened is some very light pruning of dead wood, there has certainly been no bonfire.

This is the very reason Badenoch herself came in for a lot of criticism about the lack of meaningful progress when she appeared before the European scrutiny committee in June. They didn’t see it as an upside.

The 600 or so to go before the end of the year (the full list is here) is simply more of the same.

3. Changes to employment law could help save businesses £1bn a year

This statement by Badenoch is about consulting business on changes to the law requiring businesses to record working hours. It isn’t known yet what changes will be made. But in fairness, some of the downsides are also about consultations too, so I have added this one to the list of upsides.

It may be that some employees could lose out if their working hours are not properly recorded but judgement on that is reserved.

4. The UK car industry has remained relatively resilient

I don’t think this can be taken as an upside. Has it remained resilient because of Brexit? I don’t believe so, if anything Brexit has made the industry less resilient and added to the uncertainty.

The article in Car Trends that was linked to in the email talks of “potential disruption to supply chains” in the automotive industry and says, “there are still non-tariff barriers, such as customs checks and regulations, that have added new costs and complexities to trade”.

Any resiliency has come at the cost of establishing “new logistics and distribution networks to bypass traditional trade routes between the UK and the EU”.

None of the major car companies as far as I know have cited Brexit as a reason to invest in the UK.

At best you could argue Brexit has made little difference and large firms can easily cope with increased red tape adding friction to supply chains. To claim it has ‘remained resilient’ really can’t justify being considered an upside.

5. We got ahead in the vaccine race

The Guardian article linked to is from 2021 and about securing a supply of vaccines, rather than approving vaccines. Suggestions the UK was able to approve the first vaccine because of Brexit has been debunked many times, not least by the BBC here and covered by Yorkshire Bylines in the Brexit benefit myths.

It’s true the UK was able to sign contracts for the supply of vaccines after rejecting an EU offer in 2020 to become part of a joint procurement scheme, but again this occurred while the UK was abiding by EU law during the transition period. Any EU member state could have done the same as Hungary actually did.

To argue we were able to do this because of Brexit is not true and can’t be considered an upside. Brexit may have made the decision easier or even more logical in light of the fact we were soon to be fully exiting the bloc, but it wasn’t a decision enabled by Brexit.

6. The MHRA to fast-track drugs approved in Japan, USA and Europe

The Economist article which was sent comes from May of this year and suggests that the UK’s Medicines and Healthcare-products Regulatory Agency (MHRA) will from 2024 ‘fast-track’ approvals for drugs already approved in Japan, America and Europe, which suggests the EU has approved at least some drugs that the UK has not. This seems to be a downside rather than anything else.

As far as other sectors are concerned, the same article says:

“But, in the main, attempts to impose a distinctly British regime floundered: deadlines to impose onerous new domestic approval regimes for cars, food imports and chemicals have been postponed by years, as manufacturers warned that Britain’s small market made the burden of additional bureaucracy unaffordable.”

A downside again, I think?

7. Microsoft’s acquisition of Activision blocked

Again, this is true. The UK’s Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), blocked the acquisition by Microsoft of Activision Blizzard, a publisher of video games earlier this year. The Economist article carrying this report is dated 26 April 2023.

In mid-May, the EU regulator approved the £55bn deal and in October, the CMA followed suit and approved the deal, reversing the earlier ruling.

This came after Microsoft’s president, Brad Smith, had declared the CMA decision was “bad for Britain” and that, “there’s a clear message here – the European Union is a more attractive place to start a business than the United Kingdom”.

The Economist also notes comments by James Webber of the law firm Shearman & Sterling, that the CMA is subject to less scrutiny by lawmakers and weaker review by judges than its EU counterpart.

Again, more of a downside perhaps?

8. Britain’s services exports are booming despite Brexit

This comes from an article again in The Economist from May this year asking why Britain’s service exports to the EU are up by 16% whereas goods exports have not regained their level of 2019.

The piece speculates that services firms may have found “ways to ease trade frictions” and points to research suggesting that since 2016 British firms are now more likely to sell through affiliates than directly. It concludes that “such workarounds may not last” and EU regulators may “crack down”.

It also says the extra costs could blunt the competitive edge of UK service companies over time and some may simply not bother selling to the bloc at all.

It seems to me the story implies that service exports may have increased by more than 16% without Brexit, so again not really an upside.

There is also a reference to Britain’s office drones making inroads into some smaller markets, particularly economies with which the country has historic ties such as India, the United Arab Emirates and Nigeria. It’s hard to see how Brexit helped since the EU never prevented the UK exporting to those countries in any case.

Brexit: despatches from the downside. Cartoon of the Downside Bunker
Brexit

Despatches from the downside – No 12

by Anthony Robinson
7 December 2023 - Updated on 22 December 2023

9. Indian students have more than offset a drop in demand for education from the EU

Again this is true, but the UK has always had the right to attract students from India and elsewhere, although Brexit has introduced new rules, we could have implemented the same rules for non-EU students before Brexit.

It can hardly be claimed as an upside.

10. The amount of fish caught and landed by UK boats has been rising

This is a claim made in December 2022 by Mark Spencer MP as fisheries minister and covered by the BBC in a Verify Report. It is true the tonnage increased from 622,000 in 2019 to 652,000 in 2022, an increase of 4.8%.

However, Dr Bryce Stewart, a fisheries biologist from the University of York, says the government has “overstated the longer term impact” because most of the benefit came in 2021, following the transfer of 15% of the EU’s quota, with much smaller transfers to come up to 2026.

There were also winners and losers. Peterhead and Lerwick gained the majority of the extra fish while ports in north-east England – Hull, Grimsby and Bridlington – as well as in the south-west – Plymouth and Newlyn – all saw decreases in their 2019 catches.

Overall, the report is in my opinion more negative than positive. Chris Ranford of the Cornish Fish Producers Organisation said things have been “extremely painful”. Jane Sandell of UK Fisheries, owners of the super-trawler ‘Kirkella’ said they had to make 72 fishermen redundant and Juliette Hatchman of South Western Fish Producers called the sheer cost of all the additional export paperwork “quite eye-watering”.

I would hesitate to describe the modest tonnage increase as an upside related to Brexit, especially as the government’s own figures show in 2016 total landings were 936,200 tonnes.

Moreover, the published data for 2022 says: “UK vessels landed 640 thousand tonnes of sea fish with a value of £1.04bn. Compared to 2021, this is a decrease of 2% in quantity, however an increase in value of 13%. The increase in value is mainly driven by higher fish prices.”

So, that’s it. Out of ten suggestions there is one potential upside which I’ve now added to our list, bringing the total number of recorded Brexit upsides to 34.

What I think this exercise shows is how difficult it is to find ‘considerable’ upsides which is what David Davis promised us all back in 2016.

Sign up for the Yorkshire Bylines newsletter

* indicates required

Consent for having Bylines Network store my submitted information

You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of our emails. For information about our privacy practices, please visit our website.

We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking below to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing. Learn more about Mailchimp's privacy practices.

Anthony Robinson

Anthony Robinson

Anthony is a retired sales engineer, living in North Yorkshire. He has represented several European manufacturers of packaging machinery in the UK. Anthony is interested in politics, although not as an active member of any party, and enjoys reading, gardening and DIY. Follow him on Bluesky

Related Posts

Chelmsford, Essex, United Kingdom - May 08th 2026: Reform UK Leader Nigel Farage speaks at Chelmsford Race Track after sweeping local election victories for his party. Credit: Will Colebourne
Home Affairs

‘Reforming’ Britain? A window to the past

by Dr Pam Jarvis
30 October 2026
25/09/2026. Manchester, United Kingdom. Prime Minister Andy Burnham holds media interviews in No10 North. Picture by Lauren Hurley / No 10 Downing Street
Home Affairs

Burnham’s bold plan for social care reform

by Lucca Di Virgilio
10 October 2026 - Updated on 18 October 2026
AI, artificial intelligence, in modern medical technology. IOT and automation.
Home Affairs

Yorkshire’s NHS needs authority budgets before AI agents act

by Dr Gleb Tsipursky
1 October 2026
Meta and Oakley Smart Glasses
Home Affairs

New employment rights open the door to tech workers

by Tony Burke
30 September 2026
Drone photograph showing the very low water levels in Scar House Reservoir during the 2025 heatwave and drought. Months of below average rainfall have left the reservoirs looking very dry
Environment

Will there be enough water to satisfy demand in 2050? Part two

by Patrick Wright
9 September 2026
Next Post
The Bay Area of San Francisco during the 2020 fires

What if it’s too late? Facing the consequences of climate change

PLEASE SUPPORT OUR CROWDFUNDER

BROWSE BY TAGS

Art Books Boris Johnson Bradford Charity Climate Change Cost of Living Covid-19 Creative Industries Crime Democracy Devolution Donald Trump Environment Equality Experience Farming Festival Gaza Conflict General Election History Human Rights Immigration Iran Journalism Keir Starmer Labour Leeds Media Mental Health NHS Northern Ireland Protocol Pollution Poverty Recipe Refugees and Asylum Seekers Restaurants Retained EU Law Review Rishi Sunak Sheffield Theatre Travel Ukraine USA
Yorkshire Bylines

We are a not-for-profit citizen journalism publication. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Yorkshire and beyond.

Yorkshire Bylines is a trading brand of Bylines Networks Limited which is separate to, but allied with, Byline Times.

Learn more about us

No Result
View All Result
  • About
  • Authors and editors
  • Complaints
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Letters
  • Privacy
  • Network Map
  • Network RSS Feeds
  • Submission Guidelines
  • Download the Bylines Network App

© 2020-2026 Yorkshire Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9720

No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Home Affairs
    • Transport
    • World
  • Politics
  • Opinion
  • Society
    • Culture
    • Dance
    • Food
    • Music
    • Poetry
    • Recipes
    • Sport
  • Business
    • Economy
    • Science and Technology
    • Trade
  • Region
  • The Davis Downside Dossier
  • The Digby Jones Index
  • Cartoons by Stan
  • Authors and editors

Newsletter sign up

CROWDFUNDER

© 2020-2026 Yorkshire Bylines. Powerful Citizen Journalism. ISSN 3049-9720