• Contact
  • About
  • Authors
DONATE
NEWSLETTER SIGN UP
  • Login
Yorkshire Bylines
  • Home
  • News
    • All
    • Brexit
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Home Affairs
    • Transport
    • World
    Prime minister PMQ prep

    Brexit isn’t working – something we can all agree on

    The small number of trees shows that even the high uplands of the Dales was a woodland environment. Much has been nibbled down to the ground by heavy populations of sheep. Photo by Andy Brown

    Government policies destroying upland Yorkshire farming with no regard for the land or our health

    schools bill

    Johnson’s education power grab: from ‘liberation’ to dictatorship in one generation

    Emmanuel Macron

    French parliamentary elections 2022: shockwaves across the Channel

    Rail strikes

    Millions affected by biggest rail strike action in 30 years

    cost of living march london

    Trade union movement marches to demand better

    European Union

    After the seismic shocks of Brexit and Covid, what next for the European Union?

    Eurovision 2022 stage - photo by Michael Doherty on Wikimedia Commons licensed by CC BY-SA 4.0

    What does Ukraine’s Eurovision win tell us about the politics of solidarity?

    Refugee Week

    Refugee week: a chance to celebrate refugees

    Trending Tags

    • Johnson
    • Coronavirus
    • Labour
    • Starmer
    • NI Protocol
    • Brexit
    • Culture
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Home Affairs
    • Transport
    • World
  • Politics
  • Opinion
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Culture
    • Dance
    • Food
    • Music
    • Poetry
    • Recipes
    • Sport
    Nostell Priory, Wakefield

    Glastonbury? What’s Glastonbury? When the music world came to Wakefield

    Headingley Cricket Stadium

    A view from the Roses match: is everything ‘rosey’ in English cricket?

    Bettys' Fat Rascals

    Scallywags, scoundrels and rascals abound in Yorkshire (we do like our scones)

    'Woke' beliefs

    Woke and proud: Compassion must never be allowed to go out of fashion

    Eurovision 2022 stage - photo by Michael Doherty on Wikimedia Commons licensed by CC BY-SA 4.0

    What does Ukraine’s Eurovision win tell us about the politics of solidarity?

    Red Ladder

    Climbing the Red Ladder – bringing theatre to the community

    Kaiser Chiefs in Doncaster

    Kaiser Chiefs never miss a beat in Doncaster

    Bradford Council leader Councillor Susan Hinchcliffe, second from right, is joined by Keighley Creative representatives, from left, Georgina Webster, Jan Smithies and Gemma Hobbs.

    Bradford announced as City of Culture 2025

    Queen cakes fit for a Queen

    Queen Cakes fit for the Queen’s Platinum Jubilee

    • Food
    • Music
    • Poetry
    • Sport
  • Business
    • All
    • Economy
    • Technology
    • Trade
    Freya Osment from Northern Gas Networks

    International Women in Engineering Day 2022

    Rail strikes

    Millions affected by biggest rail strike action in 30 years

    conservative party

    The Conservative Party: fiscally irresponsible and ideologically incapable of addressing the current crises

    Yorkshire cows

    British farmers are being offered a lump sum payment to leave the industry – but at what cost to agriculture?

    cost-of-living-crisis-in-voluntary-sector

    Cost-of-living crisis looming for the voluntary sector

    Money on the floor - £20 notes

    The huge cost of Brexit is being seriously understated

    Financial problems

    Surge in bad debt and late payments indicate mounting business distress in Yorkshire

    An evening photo tour of Drax power station near Selby, North Yorkshire, with excellent light towards sunset.

    Winter blackouts and rationing for six million homes as government plans for disruption to energy supply

    Jar with money cascading out of it

    Boosterism doesn’t put food on the table

    Trending Tags

      • Economy
      • Technology
      • Trade
    • Region
    No Result
    View All Result
    • Home
    • News
      • All
      • Brexit
      • Education
      • Environment
      • Health
      • Home Affairs
      • Transport
      • World
      Prime minister PMQ prep

      Brexit isn’t working – something we can all agree on

      The small number of trees shows that even the high uplands of the Dales was a woodland environment. Much has been nibbled down to the ground by heavy populations of sheep. Photo by Andy Brown

      Government policies destroying upland Yorkshire farming with no regard for the land or our health

      schools bill

      Johnson’s education power grab: from ‘liberation’ to dictatorship in one generation

      Emmanuel Macron

      French parliamentary elections 2022: shockwaves across the Channel

      Rail strikes

      Millions affected by biggest rail strike action in 30 years

      cost of living march london

      Trade union movement marches to demand better

      European Union

      After the seismic shocks of Brexit and Covid, what next for the European Union?

      Eurovision 2022 stage - photo by Michael Doherty on Wikimedia Commons licensed by CC BY-SA 4.0

      What does Ukraine’s Eurovision win tell us about the politics of solidarity?

      Refugee Week

      Refugee week: a chance to celebrate refugees

      Trending Tags

      • Johnson
      • Coronavirus
      • Labour
      • Starmer
      • NI Protocol
      • Brexit
      • Culture
      • Education
      • Environment
      • Home Affairs
      • Transport
      • World
    • Politics
    • Opinion
    • Lifestyle
      • All
      • Culture
      • Dance
      • Food
      • Music
      • Poetry
      • Recipes
      • Sport
      Nostell Priory, Wakefield

      Glastonbury? What’s Glastonbury? When the music world came to Wakefield

      Headingley Cricket Stadium

      A view from the Roses match: is everything ‘rosey’ in English cricket?

      Bettys' Fat Rascals

      Scallywags, scoundrels and rascals abound in Yorkshire (we do like our scones)

      'Woke' beliefs

      Woke and proud: Compassion must never be allowed to go out of fashion

      Eurovision 2022 stage - photo by Michael Doherty on Wikimedia Commons licensed by CC BY-SA 4.0

      What does Ukraine’s Eurovision win tell us about the politics of solidarity?

      Red Ladder

      Climbing the Red Ladder – bringing theatre to the community

      Kaiser Chiefs in Doncaster

      Kaiser Chiefs never miss a beat in Doncaster

      Bradford Council leader Councillor Susan Hinchcliffe, second from right, is joined by Keighley Creative representatives, from left, Georgina Webster, Jan Smithies and Gemma Hobbs.

      Bradford announced as City of Culture 2025

      Queen cakes fit for a Queen

      Queen Cakes fit for the Queen’s Platinum Jubilee

      • Food
      • Music
      • Poetry
      • Sport
    • Business
      • All
      • Economy
      • Technology
      • Trade
      Freya Osment from Northern Gas Networks

      International Women in Engineering Day 2022

      Rail strikes

      Millions affected by biggest rail strike action in 30 years

      conservative party

      The Conservative Party: fiscally irresponsible and ideologically incapable of addressing the current crises

      Yorkshire cows

      British farmers are being offered a lump sum payment to leave the industry – but at what cost to agriculture?

      cost-of-living-crisis-in-voluntary-sector

      Cost-of-living crisis looming for the voluntary sector

      Money on the floor - £20 notes

      The huge cost of Brexit is being seriously understated

      Financial problems

      Surge in bad debt and late payments indicate mounting business distress in Yorkshire

      An evening photo tour of Drax power station near Selby, North Yorkshire, with excellent light towards sunset.

      Winter blackouts and rationing for six million homes as government plans for disruption to energy supply

      Jar with money cascading out of it

      Boosterism doesn’t put food on the table

      Trending Tags

        • Economy
        • Technology
        • Trade
      • Region
      No Result
      View All Result
      Yorkshire Bylines
      No Result
      View All Result
      Home News Brexit

      Article 16: is Britain to become a rule breaker or a rule taker?

      An authoritative legal argument suggests Johnson has little choice but to proceed with the hated Northern Ireland protocol.

      Anthony RobinsonbyAnthony Robinson
      09-11-2021 12:27
      in Brexit, News, Politics, World
      Court of Justice of the European Union, by Luxofluxo, CC BY-SA 4.0 , via Wikimedia Commons

      Court of Justice of the European Union, by Luxofluxo, CC BY-SA 4.0 , via Wikimedia Commons

      2.7k
      VIEWS
      Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
      ADVERTISEMENT

      A leading professor of international law has produced a detailed legal argument casting serious doubt on the lawfulness of Boris Johnson’s plan to use article 16 of the Northern Ireland protocol as a prelude to renegotiating its terms. The implication of the opinion is that Britain must choose to be a rule breaker or a rule taker.

      The prime minister is said to be seeking legal advice about using article 16, even though the government already has the benefit of an entire legal department staffed with 2,000 solicitors and lawyers. It clearly doesn’t like the advice being offered.

      Now, Robert L Howse, a recognised authority on international law at New York University Law School, has produced a legal opinion about the matter, published by the Brexit Institute of Dublin City University. It will offer little comfort to Lord Frost. 

      It is 24 pages of detailed and impeccably argued logic, written with stunning clarity. 

      Article 16 is not an escape route out of the Northern Ireland protocol

      The triggering of article 16 is not an escape route out of the problems of the protocol. It is more of a short circular tour that keeps returning you to the same conclusion. You cannot have a hard Brexit without an international border in the Irish Sea. Howse suggests that the text of article 16 does not authorise “any derogation from the hard legal obligations in the Protocol”.

      According to the distinguished professor:

      “Even a cursory reading of Article 16 shows that it is not the kind of provision designed to trigger renegotiation or even permanent adjustment of specific commitments or mechanisms in the Protocol.”

      He argues that article 16 is about managing the protocol under circumstances where the application of it leads to “serious economic, societal or environmental difficulties that are liable to persist, or to diversion of trade”. But all the provisions are about limited, temporary measures to ‘safeguard’ the protocol; to overcome temporary issues, but always returning as quickly as possible to the text as it was agreed in October 2019. Whatever the problems with the protocol, Howse is very clear that article 16 “is not a renegotiation clause”.

      The Irish trilemma could easily be resolved by regulatory harmonisation

      On the so-called Irish trilemma (leaving the single market and the customs union (Brexit) while ensuring no hard border on the island of Ireland, or any form of border in the Irish Sea) he has this to say about balancing the apparently irreconcilable objectives:

      “Much of the problem of balancing the objectives stems from a political decision in the UK in fact to reject a post-Brexit solution that would maintain harmonization of regulatory standards with the EU, at least those particularly relevant to goods traded between Great Britain and Ireland. Although the TCA would allow for tariff-free trade between the UK and the EU, the predominant political ideology of Brexit set up a taboo concerning regulatory harmonization, though on any rational theory of public interest, the losses to the UK from harmonization would be likely minimal” [our emphasis].

      Robert L Howse

      In fact, it is rather worse than Howse suggests. There are no losses and only substantial gains in keeping regulatory harmony, as the government’s own estimates have shown repeatedly since 2016. However, his message is unlikely to be well received in Downing Street.

      Sinn Féin / CC BY (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0)
      Brexit

      Lords committee lambasts government mishandling of the NI protocol

      byAnthony Robinson
      3 June 2020

      Measures permitted under article 16 are limited to those ‘strictly necessary’

      The protocol says that either side can take ‘safeguarding’ measures, and in response the other side can adopt ‘rebalancing’ measures, but both must be “strictly necessary in order to remedy the situation”.

      The term ‘strictly necessary’ when read together with the additional requirement that “priority shall be given to such measures as will least disturb the functioning of the Protocol”, may be taken, says Professor Howse, to imply something like a ‘least restrictive means test’. This is a familiar term from World Trade Organization jurisprudence.

      He then says, with devastating logic, that:

      “Under a least restrictive means test, a problem for the UK in invoking Article 16 in respect of the border in the Irish sea is that there is a clear alternative measure capable of being taken by the UK unilaterally that would avoid the difficulties in question.

      “This would be to engage in regulatory harmonization or an equivalence exercise. Of course, not to do so, as already mentioned, was a political or ideological choice.

      “But that could not be a valid reason for rejecting an alternative measure less disruptive. Because a party could always say that it doesn’t want to choose the alternative for political reasons, which would render the legal discipline of strict necessity impossible to apply.

      “The UK, I would predict, would have a difficult time, showing on a reasonableness standard that harmonization would threaten some essential legitimate interest, as (while it was in the EU) the UK and its economic actors were able to live quite well with such harmonization” [our emphasis].

      He concludes that, “Absent regulatory harmonization, the only response to border control difficulties arising from the trilemma is to redouble working level cooperation and try to make the arrangements more efficient. Managing the temperature of political rhetoric and avoiding the legally untutored brandishing of Article 16 of a weapon would be positive steps. The EU at least seems still prepared to roll up its sleeves and work constructively for better outcomes on the ground, so the ball is in the UK court”.

      It is hard to disagree.

      Is the protocol the cause of the ‘serious difficulties’

      Mr Howse also makes a serious point that the ‘serious difficulties’ referred to in article 16 must be caused by the application of the Protocol itself. This is the opening phrase of article 16(1).

      He says it might be difficult to make this accusation stick. Some of the arguments used in the UK government’s command paper including some increase in tensions between the North and South, “could be more plausibly attributed to Brexit itself and the inherent difficulty of maintaining the delicate equilibrium in the Belfast Good Friday Agreement while removing the UK from the EU.”

      Frost and Šefčovič are to meet again this week

      Lord Frost and EU Vice President Maroš Šefčovič are due to meet again on Friday, with reports that the EU is trying hard to persuade the UK not to reach for article 16 at all. One senior EU official is quoted directly saying, “In order to avoid escalation, you have to demonstrate escalation dominance”.

      To dissuade UKG from triggering Article 16, EU is drawing up a package of short/medium term retaliatory measures which cd be put to @DavidGHFrost by @MarosSefcovic on Fri. As one senior official says: "In order to avoid escalation, you have to demonstrate escalation dominance" 1/

      — Mujtaba Rahman (@Mij_Europe) November 9, 2021

      This apparently means explaining to Lord Frost the range of potential retaliatory measures that the EU is prepared to use if article 16 is invoked. They could include short-term tariffs a well as a suspension of the trade and cooperation agreement TCA in the medium term.

      The UK government appears to be trapped. Either it accepts the Northern Ireland protocol as agreed in 2019 and works towards implementing it in good faith with whatever easements it can persuade the EU to adopt, or it goes for more regulatory harmonisation, otherwise known as BRINO (Brexit in name only).

      The only other option is to become a rule breaker, an international pariah who cannot be trusted to comply with obligations it freely entered into.

      Tags: NI Protocol
      ADVERTISEMENT
      Previous Post

      Review of the Holocaust Galleries at the Imperial War Museum

      Next Post

      Why MPs will never give up their second jobs

      Anthony Robinson

      Anthony Robinson

      Anthony is a retired sales engineer, living in North Yorkshire. He has represented several European manufacturers of packaging machinery in the UK. Anthony is interested in politics, although not as an active member of any party, and enjoys reading, gardening and DIY.

      Related Posts

      Prime minister PMQ prep
      Brexit

      Brexit isn’t working – something we can all agree on

      byAnthony Robinson
      28 June 2022
      The small number of trees shows that even the high uplands of the Dales was a woodland environment. Much has been nibbled down to the ground by heavy populations of sheep. Photo by Andy Brown
      Environment

      Government policies destroying upland Yorkshire farming with no regard for the land or our health

      byAndy Brown
      27 June 2022
      schools bill
      Education

      Johnson’s education power grab: from ‘liberation’ to dictatorship in one generation

      byDr Pam Jarvis
      27 June 2022
      Conservative Party Meeting
      Politics

      Hypocrisy, desperation and excuses: Conservative Party clutch at straws over by-election losses

      bySue Wilson MBE
      27 June 2022
      10/05/2022 Prime Minister Boris Johnson at the House of Commons. Picture by Andrew Parsons / No 10 Downing Street
      Politics

      The country needs more than just ‘Booting Boris out of Downing Street’

      byDr Stella Perrott
      26 June 2022
      Next Post
      Angela Smith, former MP

      Why MPs will never give up their second jobs

      Want to support us?

      Can you help Yorkshire Bylines to grow and become more sustainable with a regular donation, no matter how small?  

      DONATE

      Sign up to our newsletter

      If you would like to receive the Yorkshire Bylines regular newsletter, straight talking direct to your inbox, click the button below.

      NEWSLETTER

      LATEST

      Prime minister PMQ prep

      Brexit isn’t working – something we can all agree on

      28 June 2022
      The small number of trees shows that even the high uplands of the Dales was a woodland environment. Much has been nibbled down to the ground by heavy populations of sheep. Photo by Andy Brown

      Government policies destroying upland Yorkshire farming with no regard for the land or our health

      27 June 2022
      schools bill

      Johnson’s education power grab: from ‘liberation’ to dictatorship in one generation

      27 June 2022
      Conservative Party Meeting

      Hypocrisy, desperation and excuses: Conservative Party clutch at straws over by-election losses

      27 June 2022

      MOST READ

      schools bill

      Johnson’s education power grab: from ‘liberation’ to dictatorship in one generation

      27 June 2022
      Conservative Party Meeting

      Hypocrisy, desperation and excuses: Conservative Party clutch at straws over by-election losses

      27 June 2022
      10/05/2022 Prime Minister Boris Johnson at the House of Commons. Picture by Andrew Parsons / No 10 Downing Street

      The country needs more than just ‘Booting Boris out of Downing Street’

      26 June 2022
      Photo credit Robert Sharp / englishpenLicensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 2.0 Generic license.

      The Davis Downside Dossier

      1 January 2021

      BROWSE BY TAGS

      antivaxxers Charity climate change Coronavirus Cost of living Creative industries Crime Cummings Democracy Devolution education Equality Farming Fishing hgv History Immigration Johnson Journalism Labour Local Democracy Mental Health mining money NHS NI Protocol omicron Pies pollution poverty PPE Public Health Review shortage social media Starmer tax travel Ukraine Yorkshire
      Yorkshire Bylines

      Yorkshire Bylines is a regional online newspaper that supports citizen journalism. Our aim is to publish well-written, fact-based articles and opinion pieces on subjects that are of interest to people in Yorkshire and beyond.

      Learn more about us

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Contact
      • About
      • Letters
      • Donate
      • Privacy
      • Bylines network
      • Shop

      © 2022 Yorkshire Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • News
        • Brexit
        • Education
        • Environment
        • Health
        • Home Affairs
        • Transport
        • World
      • Politics
      • Opinion
      • Lifestyle
        • Culture
        • Dance
        • Food
        • Music
        • Poetry
        • Recipes
        • Sport
      • Business
        • Economy
        • Technology
        • Trade
      • Donate
      • The Compendium of Cabinet Codebreakers
      • The Davis Downside Dossier
      • The Digby Jones Index
      • Newsletter sign up
      • Cartoons by Stan
      • Authors

      © 2022 Yorkshire Bylines. Citizen Journalism | Local & Internationalist

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password?

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In