The economic model known as capitalism has been with us for many centuries in many different forms. Perhaps one of the earliest recognised and recorded manifestations would be the Hanseatic League, dating from the 14th century, in which a dozen or more seaports around the Baltic and North Seas co-operated in mutually beneficial trading arrangements. This cosy set-up ended when the small global area involved became unable to fulfil all the demands of its populace, and merchants (and nations) turned towards the rest of the world into which to expand their empires.
Most forms of capitalism have, sooner or later, similarly foundered, for reasons which their proponents would describe as unfortunate, unforeseen circumstances (such as the unpropitious frequency of sunspots: yes, really, that was the accepted explanation for some considerable time for the booms and busts of trade) which could be easily adjusted or accommodated, but which their opponents would describe as inevitable and inbuilt.
Capitalism at its most basic
The basic capitalist model relies on simple principles: cash investments are made with the expectation of bringing later rewards of larger sums of cash. That is, larger in real terms, not simply larger as the result of general inflation. Capital is sent out to bring back more capital.
If cash, as paper money, has value only when it can be converted into real wealth as commodities or services, then larger sums of cash need more commodities or more services; such increases then require more resources such as raw materials and energy and will create more in the way of waste products.
It is therefore clear that in defined circumstances, the demand for extra resources and energy will inevitably reach the limits of those circumstances, and capital will need to seek new territories to continue its expansion. A simple example would be the Ponzi selling scheme, in which a tiny number of initiators will ‘make’ large sums of money from their initial sales, but where subsequent layers of sellers will find ever greater difficulties in finding ready markets – to the point where the last to join will lose everything. Financial ‘bubbles’ also illustrate this point. Growth and expansion cannot continue for ever, because everything is finite; it really is just simple mathematics.
20th-century progress?
The 20th century could be regarded as the century of worker organisation and advancement. Trades Unions became better organised; sympathetic governments passed legislation which eventually responded to the feelings of those caught up in two World Wars: that having fought for their country they deserved something better than the poverty and exploitation of the Victorian age. The Downton Abbey and the Satanic Mill models of existence were doomed to history.
In many countries including the UK and the USA, the ratio between the highest and the lowest earners reached its smallest value just after the second world war and the UK worker protection legislation of the 1970s was the most radical and beneficial that had ever been seen. It seemed that raw rampant capitalism had at last been tamed into something which had benefits for everyone domestically.
Neoliberalism
But this was not good enough for the world’s wealthy, and new manifestations of capitalism began to be propounded during the seventies to reach full maturity under Reagan and Thatcher. We had the ‘monetarism’ of Milton Friedman and Friedrich von Hayek and the ultimate global model of so-called neoliberalism.
It sounded good: it was new, and it was liberal, who could object? And it was based on an unfettered free market – free from government control or ‘interference’, including trade tariffs! But it proved to be just about the most exploitative form of capitalism yet, creating small numbers of hyper-billionaires alongside massive world-wide wealth-gaps and outright poverty.
One of the techniques of neoliberalism was to scatter a production process about the globe so that, say, research and development with top level management took place in a North-Western country with high labour charges; manufacture and assembly were sent away to low labour-cost countries in the Global south; while the final sales and marketing were brought back to the north. Thus, the north benefits from what is in effect a transfer of labour value from the south; but in particular, it would be a very few hyper-rich individuals who pocketed the benefits.
By this process, we have seen the gap between the wealthiest and the poorest become the biggest since the 19th century with record numbers of millionaires, multi-millionaires, billionaires and multi-billionaires in this country, in the USA and elsewhere.
Trump’s tariffs – a violation of neoliberalism
America collectively may feel it is worse off right now, but small numbers of Americans are decidedly not so. Trump may have some justification to feel aggrieved, but the problem lies not with the rest of the world, it lies in the outrageous avarice of small numbers of his own citizens, including many of his new ‘best friends’. Trump’s actions in imposing protective tariffs on international trade is directly contrary to the rules of neoliberalism which basically say, ‘Hands off! Let the market decide’.
But another important rule of capitalism is that when things begin to turn unfavourably, then the thing to do is to change the rules.
Changing the rules
A big example of this occurred 17 years ago when international financial institutions overreached themselves and the world had to deal with the so-called ‘sub-prime crisis’. Strictly speaking, the banks etc., should have been left to their own devices, as was the case in Iceland. But somehow, it became accepted dogma that some bodies were ‘too big to fail’ and public purses across the globe were called upon to bail out the private messes. Printing lots of extra money was called ‘quantitative easing’, but essentially, it was ‘public pain for private gain’, for which many of our public services are still paying the price.
We are now encountering neoliberalism’s second big crisis, which Trump is attempting to solve by changing the rules and starting a global tariff war.
The hypocrisy of anti-immigrant sentiment
As capitalism shifts value (ie wealth) from low-wage to high-wage areas, we cannot assume that this will go unnoticed by the losers in the exchange. Bright and bold young people across the globe see where the best opportunities lie and where the wealth of the world is accumulating, and they want to be part of it – and why not?
When this happens here, and our young entrepreneurs decide to emigrate to Australia, New Zealand, Canada, etc., in order to pursue their careers with much bigger salaries than back home, we applaud their courage and their enterprise. This observation could apply equally to two or three centuries ago as to the present day.
But when similar young people from Africa, Asia and South America seek to do the same and travel north to the relatively much better-off Europe and the USA, we despise them as ‘economic migrants’ and often brand them as ‘Illegal’.
It is arguable that the rise in global migration from the poor South to the rich North is a direct consequence of four decades of neoliberal accumulation.
How will this end? When will it end?
We cannot know, but there is a third question: Is this the final crisis for neoliberalism, and will Global capitalism need to come up with some new formulation if it is to continue?







